TGT

NYSEMIXED SIGNALS
Swing · Multi-day confirmation4 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 17, 2026, 7:50 PM · Valid for ~12h
CompletedRe-run
MIXED SIGNALS
4 models· Split decision
2 Long1 Short1 Contested
Key Disagreements
  • Split opinion: 2 model(s) LONG vs 1 model(s) SHORT
  • GPT-5.2(66% LONG): "Long-biased swing: buy near $115.6 with stop below $109.6 support and target toward $125.5 on a breakout/continuation, supported by bullish RSI, acceptance above value-area high, reasonable valuation, and supportive (risk-on/contango) macro backdrop despite mixed trend signals."
  • Gemini-3-Pro(72% LONG): "TGT is a strong value rotation play following a massive Q4 earnings beat (EPS $6.15 vs $3.18 est, +93% surprise) on Feb 6, 2026. The stock is consolidating these gains above a converging SMA 20/SMA 50 ( $114.21) , with a Golden Cross imminent. Technicals show resilience: price is holding $115 despite analyst downgrades, and the RSI (62) indicates bullish momentum with room to run. As market breadth expands (RSP > SPY) , capital is rotating into high-quality cyclical retailers, positioning Target for a breakout above $118 toward recent highs."
BULL (2)
BEAR (1)
0%1 skip0%
Bull Case(3 models)
Gemini-3-Pro0%

TGT is a strong value rotation play following a massive Q4 earnings beat (EPS $6.15 vs $3.18 est, +93% surprise) on Feb 6, 2026. The stock is consolidating these gains above a converging SMA 20/SMA 50 ( $114.21) , with a Golden Cross imminent. Technicals show resilience: price is holding $115 despite analyst downgrades, and the RSI (62) indicates bullish momentum with room to run. As market breadth expands (RSP > SPY) , capital is rotating into high-quality cyclical retailers, positioning Target for a breakout above $118 toward recent highs.

GPT-5.20%

TGT is holding above a well-defined support zone (~$109.6) and is trading above its short-term moving averages with bullish momentum (4h RSI ~62.7 rising), suggesting buyers are in control on pullbacks. Price is also above the volume profile value-area high (~$114.2), which often signals acceptance higher and sets up a potential push through the nearby resistance (~$118.3) into the next upside zone, with the low-volume pocket above current price implying faster movement if it breaks. Fundamentally, TGT screens as reasonably valued for a defensive retailer (P/E ~14, EV/EBITDA ~8.6, P/S ~0.5) and recently delivered a major positive EPS surprise (Feb 6), which can support continued re-rating if the broader tape stays constructive.

DeepSeek-R1

TGT shows technical strength trading above key SMAs with bullish RSI(61), suggesting accumulation. Fundamentally undervalued with P/E(14) below sector average, supported by a 93% EPS beat last quarter. Market regime transition favors defensive consumer staples, while volume profile shows current price breaking above high-volume node resistance at $114.16, opening path to $118.3 resistance. Recent 30% 3-month momentum indicates institutional buying despite headline outflows.

Bear Case(2 models)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

TGT is trapped in a low-volume zone at $115.57, approaching resistance at $118.30 with minimal volume support—volume profile shows current price near low volume nodes (116.92 at 3.7% relative volume, 117.84 at 0.2%) . Institutional selling is accelerating with Shell Asset Management dumping 65.4% of its position, while major analysts are slashing targets—JPM organ cut to $100, BofA and Bernstein to $80 with "Underperform" ratings. The stock is 12.25% below its 52-week high with 20 of 33 analysts rating "Hold" in a cautious stance. Price is only 2.3% from resistance but 5.5% above support at $109.59, creating unfavorable risk/reward for longs. The post-earnings euphoria appears exhausted with sideways consolidation near resistance, and next earnings not until March 1st provides no near-term catalyst while macro transition regime introduces rotation risk away from mega-retailers.

DeepSeek-R1

Technical structure shows bearish SMA 20 SMA 50 crossover with RSI divergence at 61.16. Prices its near low volume resistance node ( $116.92) with2.3 upside to major resistance ( $118.3) . Highdebt (132 D E ratio) andthin3.6 profit margins create vulnerability to consumer spending slowdown. Transitional market regime increases volatility risk for highly correlated retailers.

What Would Create an Edge
  • Close above $118.30 resistance on strong volume (>6M shares) , or any pre-announcement of positive March earnings guidance
  • Daily close below $109.50 (breakdown under key support).
  • Close below $111.90 (breaking the recent consolidation low and SMA support).
DeepSeek R1Deep
Analysis Outcome
NO TRADE0% edge
BULL
70%
BEAR
70%

Bull and bear cases balanced — no clear edge

Bull/Bear CompetitionBALANCED
Bull 70%Δ 0%Bear 70%
Bull Case

TGT shows technical strength trading above key SMAs with bullish RSI(61), suggesting accumulation. Fundamentally undervalued with P/E(14) below sector average, supported by a 93% EPS beat last quarter. Market regime transition favors defensive consumer staples, while volume profile shows current price breaking above high-volume node resistance at $114.16, opening path to $118.3 resistance. Recent 30% 3-month momentum indicates institutional buying despite headline outflows.

Bear Case

Technical structure shows bearish SMA 20 SMA 50 crossover with RSI divergence at 61.16. Prices its near low volume resistance node ( $116.92) with2.3 upside to major resistance ( $118.3) . Highdebt (132 D E ratio) andthin3.6 profit margins create vulnerability to consumer spending slowdown. Transitional market regime increases volatility risk for highly correlated retailers.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition CONTESTED: BULL case (70%) vs BEAR case (70%) - confidence delta (0%) below threshold. Trade skipped due to insufficient conviction.

11m 24s25 tools
Claude Sonnet 4.5Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
2.77R·74% confidence
Entry
$115.57
Target
$108.00
Stop
$118.30

TGT is trapped in a low-volume zone at $115.57, approaching resistance at $118.30 with minimal volume support—volume profile shows current price near low volume nodes (116.92 at 3.7% relative volume, 117.84 at 0.2%) . Institutional selling is accelerating with Shell Asset Management dumping 65.4% of its position, while major analysts are slashing targets—JPM organ cut to $100, BofA and Bernstein to $80 with "Underperform" ratings. The stock is 12.25% below its 52-week high with 20 of 33 analysts rating "Hold" in a cautious stance. Price is only 2.3% from resistance but 5.5% above support at $109.59, creating unfavorable risk/reward for longs. The post-earnings euphoria appears exhausted with sideways consolidation near resistance, and next earnings not until March 1st provides no near-term catalyst while macro transition regime introduces rotation risk away from mega-retailers.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 74%Δ 1%Bull 73%
Bear Case

TGT is trapped in a low-volume zone at $115.57, approaching resistance at $118.30 with minimal volume support—volume profile shows current price near low volume nodes (116.92 at 3.7% relative volume, 117.84 at 0.2%) . Institutional selling is accelerating with Shell Asset Management dumping 65.4% of its position, while major analysts are slashing targets—JPM organ cut to $100, BofA and Bernstein to $80 with "Underperform" ratings. The stock is 12.25% below its 52-week high with 20 of 33 analysts rating "Hold" in a cautious stance. Price is only 2.3% from resistance but 5.5% above support at $109.59, creating unfavorable risk/reward for longs. The post-earnings euphoria appears exhausted with sideways consolidation near resistance, and next earnings not until March 1st provides no near-term catalyst while macro transition regime introduces rotation risk away from mega-retailers.

Bull Case

TGT presents a compelling long setup with multiple bullish catalysts converging: (1) **Massive Q4 earnings beat** - the Feb 6, 2026 earnings crushed estimates with EPS of $6.15 vs $3.18 expected (93.4% surprise) , demonstrating operational excellence during the critical holiday quarter. (2) **Technical momentum building** - RSI at 62.69 with rising trend, price trading above both SMA 20/SMA 50 at $114.21, and only 2.3% below resistance at $118.30 with clear breakout potential. The stock has surged 38.5% from its 52-week low of $83.44, showing strong recovery momentum. (3) **Strategic transformation under new CEO** - leadership changes effective Feb 15 with new CMO and COO focused on "store-centric" model and cost reallocation should drive margin expansion. The company reaffirmed guidance and analysts raised targets (Baird to $110, Citi to $110, Evercore to $103) . (4) **Favorable macro backdrop** - market regime shows broadening participation with IWM outperformance and RSP/SPY strength, supporting cyclical retail plays. Deep VIX contango signals risk-on environment. (5) **Attractive valuation** - P/E of 14.03 is reasonable for a quality retailer with 25.1% ROE, and the stock trades at only 0.50x sales, suggesting significant upside to fair value near $124-130 range.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (74% vs 73%).

1m 50s33 tools
GPT-5.2Balanced
Analysis Outcome
LONGLEANING
1.60R·66% confidence
Entry
$115.60
Target
$125.50
Stop
$109.40

Long-biased swing: buy near $115.6 with stop below $109.6 support and target toward $125.5 on a breakout/continuation, supported by bullish RSI, acceptance above value-area high, reasonable valuation, and supportive (risk-on/contango) macro backdrop despite mixed trend signals.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 66%Δ 3%Bear 63%
Bull Case

TGT is holding above a well-defined support zone (~$109.6) and is trading above its short-term moving averages with bullish momentum (4h RSI ~62.7 rising), suggesting buyers are in control on pullbacks. Price is also above the volume profile value-area high (~$114.2), which often signals acceptance higher and sets up a potential push through the nearby resistance (~$118.3) into the next upside zone, with the low-volume pocket above current price implying faster movement if it breaks. Fundamentally, TGT screens as reasonably valued for a defensive retailer (P/E ~14, EV/EBITDA ~8.6, P/S ~0.5) and recently delivered a major positive EPS surprise (Feb 6), which can support continued re-rating if the broader tape stays constructive.

Bear Case

Technically, TGT is pressing into a defined resistance zone (~ $118.30) while the trend is still sideways and the structure shows a bearish tilt (SMA20 < SMA50) , setting up a fade/rejection rather than a clean breakout. Volume profile shows price is sitting in a low-volume node near ~ $116.9– $117.8 (poor acceptance) , which often leads to a fast move back into the high-volume “value” area (~ $114.16) and potentially a retest of support near ~ $109.6. Fundamentally/sentiment-wise, margins are thin (~3.6%) with high leverage (debt-to-equity ~132) and recent news flow points to institutional trimming and lowered analyst targets, while near-term macro/event risk (high-impact US data week and tariff-related policy uncertainty) can pressure discretionary spend and retailer multiples.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (66% vs 63%).

1m 59s32 tools
Gemini 3 ProDeep
Analysis Outcome
LONGLEANING
2.00R·72% confidence
Entry
$115.60
Target
$123.00
Stop
$111.90

TGT is a strong value rotation play following a massive Q4 earnings beat (EPS $6.15 vs $3.18 est, +93% surprise) on Feb 6, 2026. The stock is consolidating these gains above a converging SMA 20/SMA 50 ( $114.21) , with a Golden Cross imminent. Technicals show resilience: price is holding $115 despite analyst downgrades, and the RSI (62) indicates bullish momentum with room to run. As market breadth expands (RSP > SPY) , capital is rotating into high-quality cyclical retailers, positioning Target for a breakout above $118 toward recent highs.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 72%Δ 7%Bear 65%
Bull Case

TGT is a strong value rotation play following a massive Q4 earnings beat (EPS $6.15 vs $3.18 est, +93% surprise) on Feb 6, 2026. The stock is consolidating these gains above a converging SMA 20/SMA 50 ( $114.21) , with a Golden Cross imminent. Technicals show resilience: price is holding $115 despite analyst downgrades, and the RSI (62) indicates bullish momentum with room to run. As market breadth expands (RSP > SPY) , capital is rotating into high-quality cyclical retailers, positioning Target for a breakout above $118 toward recent highs.

Bear Case

TGT presents a compelling 'fade the rally' setup driven by a sharp divergence between recent price action and institutional sentiment. Despite a post-earnings bounce, major institutions like Shell Asset Management have slashed positions by over 65%, and key analysts (JPM organ, BofA) have downgraded targets to $80- $100, well below current levels. Technically, price is extending into a Low Volume Node resistance block ( $116- $118) above the Value Area High ( $114.16) . A failure to hold above this value area suggests a mean-reversion rotation back to the Point of Control at $104.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (72% vs 65%).

2m 05s22 tools
TGT Analysis | TradeHorde