WIN+8.6%+3.5R|LONGCONDITIONAL_SETUP|$283.10$307.501d 14h

IBM

NYSEBULLISH CONSENSUS
All Horizons · Multi-timeframe synthesis4 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 2, 2026, 12:17 AM · Valid for ~48h
CompletedRe-run
BULLISH CONSENSUS
4 models· Low conviction*
2 Long2 Short
Target$275.00–$340.00
Entry$259.19–$307.00
Stop$250.00–$290.00
LowConditionalHigh
Key Disagreements
  • GPT-5.2(16% SHORT): "Balanced: bull (64%) and bear (66%) are closely matched (edge score: 2%)"
  • Claude-Opus-4.5(19% SHORT): "Balanced: bull (62%) and bear (62%) are closely matched (edge score: 0%)"
BULL (2)
BEAR (2)
0%0%
Bull Case(2 models)
GROK-40%

IBM is showing strong technical momentum with RSI above 50 and rising, price positioned above key SMAs at 297.37, and current levels near high-volume nodes around 303-306, suggesting potential for a breakout towards resistance at 320 and the 52-week high of 325. Fundamentally, recent earnings have consistently beaten estimates with positive surprises, raised guidance for revenue growth and free cash flow, and catalysts like the AMD quantum partnership, $9.5B AI backlog, and 59% mainframe revenue growth position IBM well in AI and tech sectors for upside. Despite a transitioning market regime, the positive news sentiment and IBM's defensive tech profile could benefit from any risk-on rebound, aligning with VIX contango and supporting a swing long in a sideways trend with bullish signals.

DeepSeek-R10%

Technical setup shows bullish RSI (54.56) with price above key SMAs and volume confirmation. Positioned 4.1% below resistance with consistent earnings beats (avg +7.2% surprise last 4Q). Credit spread

Bear Case(4 models)
GROK-40%

The market regime is transitioning from bull to bear with high risk, evidenced by broad equity weakness, gold crash, and commodity declines, which could pressure IBM as a tech stock correlated to broader indices. Technicals show a sideways trend with MACD flat and price still 4.1% below resistance, potentially leading to consolidation or pullback if momentum fades. Fundamentals lack detailed valuation data, but any slowdown in AI adoption or missed future earnings could exacerbate downside, especially with no immediate catalysts before April.

DeepSeek-R10%

Technical deterioration with bearish SMA crossover and resistance rejection at $319.90 aligns with broader market transition to risk-off regime (72% confidence). Commodity collapse and gold crash sign

Claude-Opus-4.50%

IBM is trading at an elevated P/E of 35.18, which is historically expensive for a legacy IT services company with low single-digit revenue growth (~5% constant currency). The market regime is transiti

GPT-5.20%

IBM is near the top of its defined range ($289.8 support / ~$319.9 resistance) and is only ~4% below resistance, which makes it a favorable location to fade if sellers defend that zone. Momentum is no

What Would Invalidate
  • Close below value area low of 294.41 on daily chart.
Claude Opus 4.5DeepMIXED
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
1.95R·19% confidence
Entry
$306.70
Target
$294.40
Stop
$313.00

Balanced: bull (62%) and bear (62%) are closely matched (edge score: 0%)

Across timeframes
DAY
SHORT
62% · leaning
SWING
BALANCED
0% · contested
POSITION
BALANCED
0% · contested
Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 62%Δ 4%Bull 58%
Bear Case

IBM is vulnerable to a pullback as the market regime is transitioning from bull to bear with 72% confidence, characterized by broad equity weakness, rising VXX (+0.99%), and strong USD flight-to-quality. The stock is trading at an elevated P/E of 35.18x - expensive for a legacy IT services company with single-digit revenue growth. Technical structure shows SMA20 < SMA50 (bearish crossover), MACD is negative at -0.408, and price is extended +3.1% above moving averages with a "sideways" trend classification. The volume profile shows low volume nodes above $316, creating a vacuum zone that suggests limited upside support, while the Value Area Low at $294.41 provides a logical downside target. With commodities collapsing -4.90% and international markets severely underperforming (EEM -2.22%), risk-off sentiment could drag high-beta tech names lower.

Bull Case

IBM presents a solid fundamental case for long-term appreciation with consistent earnings beats (4 consecutive quarters of positive EPS surprises ranging from 5.4% to 9.8%), strong AI momentum with $9.5B contracted genAI backlog, and impressive automation revenue growth (+22% YoY). The stock is trading 5.6% below its 52-week high of $324.90 while sitting 43% above its 52-week low, demonstrating strong uptrend momentum. Technically, RSI at 54.56 with a rising trend suggests bullish momentum is building, and price is trading above both SMA20 and SMA50 (+3.1%). Volume is slightly elevated at 1.1x average, supporting current price action. The stock is positioned just above the Point of Control at $303.68 and within the Value Area High at $306.77, indicating institutional accumulation at these levels.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (62% vs 58%).

2m 13s93 tools$$
GPT-5.2BalancedMIXED
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
1.52R·16% confidence
Entry
$307.00
Target
$294.50
Stop
$315.20

Balanced: bull (64%) and bear (66%) are closely matched (edge score: 2%)

Across timeframes
DAY
SHORT
67% · leaning
SWING
BALANCED
0% · contested
POSITION
BALANCED
0% · contested
Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 67%Δ 3%Bull 64%
Bear Case

Intraday structure argues for downside: IBM is sitting at the top of its value area (VAH ~$306.8) after a down session, and the broader tape is in a high-risk “transition bull-to-bear” regime with broad equity weakness, rising hedging demand (VXX up despite contango), strong USD, and commodity weakness—conditions that often pressure late-cycle leaders. Trend/momentum are not confirming upside (MACD line negative/flat) and the setup offers defined risk against the ~$316–$320 resistance while targeting a mean reversion back toward the lower value area (~$294.4) and potentially the next support (~$289.8) if risk-off accelerates.

Bull Case

IBM is holding above a key high-volume acceptance area: volume profile shows the point of control near $303.68 with price ~$306.70 sitting at/just above value area high ($306.77), which often acts as a springboard for rotation higher when defended intraday. Momentum is supportive for a 1–2 day long: 1h RSI is bullish at ~54.6 and rising, price is ~+3.1% above the 1h SMA20/50 (~$297.37), and volume is slightly elevated (~1.1x average), increasing odds of a push toward the next major resistance band ($319.90) and potentially a re-test of the 52-week high (~$324.90). Despite a high-risk tape, IBM’s recent earnings history shows multiple positive EPS surprises (e.g., +5.36% on 2026-01-28 and +9.79% on 2026-01-07), which can help support dip-buying behavior versus more speculative names over the next session.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (67% vs 64%).

2m 55s57 tools$$$
Grok-4BalancedALIGNED
Analysis Outcome
LONG
1.94R·71% confidence
Entry
$307.00
Target
$340.00
Stop
$290.00

IBM is showing strong technical momentum with RSI above 50 and rising, price positioned above key SMAs at 297.37, and current levels near high-volume nodes around 303-306, suggesting potential for a breakout towards resistance at 320 and the 52-week high of 325. Fundamentally, recent earnings have consistently beaten estimates with positive surprises, raised guidance for revenue growth and free cash flow, and catalysts like the AMD quantum partnership, $9.5B AI backlog, and 59% mainframe revenue growth position IBM well in AI and tech sectors for upside. Despite a transitioning market regime, the positive news sentiment and IBM's defensive tech profile could benefit from any risk-on rebound, aligning with VIX contango and supporting a swing long in a sideways trend with bullish signals.

Across timeframes
DAY
LONG
78% · leaning
SWING
LONG
78% · leaning
POSITION
LONG
85% · decided
Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 78%Δ 3%Bear 75%
Bull Case

IBM is showing bullish technical signals with RSI at 54.56 and rising, indicating increasing momentum, while the price is positioned above both SMA20 and SMA50 at 297.37, suggesting a supportive trend for upward movement. Recent news highlights strong Q3 results with revenue growth of 7% YoY, raised guidance for 5% revenue growth and $14B free cash flow, along with AI backlog at $9.5B and partnerships in quantum computing, providing solid fundamental catalysts for upside. Volume is 1.1x average, confirming buying interest, and with no immediate negative economic events, the stock is well-positioned for a day trade bounce towards resistance at 319.90 in a sideways market that could transition positively.

Bear Case

The market regime is transitioning from bull to bear with 72% confidence and high risk level, driven by broad equity weakness, gold crash, commodity collapse, and rising hedging demand via VXX, which could pressure IBM as a tech stock correlated to underperforming indices like QQQ down 1.20%. Technicals reveal bearish signals with SMA20 below SMA50, flat MACD, and today's -0.82% price decline, positioning the stock for a potential drop towards support at 289.79 amid sideways trend vulnerability. No immediate catalysts like earnings in the near term leave IBM exposed to macro downside risks, including strong USD and international market stress, amplifying the case for near-term intraday or next-day declines.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (78% vs 75%).

3m 46s69 tools$
DeepSeek R1DeepMIXED
Analysis Outcome
LONG
1.72R·22% confidence
Entry
$259.19
Target
$275.00
Stop
$250.00

Balanced: bull (70%) and bear (68%) are closely matched (edge score: 2%)

Across timeframes
DAY
BALANCED
0% · contested
SWING
BALANCED
0% · contested
POSITION
LONG
68% · leaning
Bull/Bear CompetitionBALANCED
Bull 70%Δ 2%Bear 68%
Bull Case

IBM shows strong technical positioning above key moving averages ($297.37) with bullish RSI (54.56) and rising momentum. Price sits near the top of the volume value area ($294.41-$306.77) with high-volume support nodes at $303.68 and $305.22. Volume is 10% above average, confirming buyer interest. As a defensive enterprise tech provider, IBM may outperform during market rotations.

Bear Case

IBM faces significant headwinds from the transitioning market regime with high risk of broad equity weakness. Technicals show bearish SMA crossover and price near resistance with no recent positive catalysts. Commodity collapse and strong USD create unfavorable macro conditions for this multinational.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition CONTESTED: BULL case (70%) vs BEAR case (68%) - confidence delta (2%) below threshold. Trade skipped due to insufficient conviction.

9m 42s58 tools$
IBM Analysis | TradeHorde