SPOT

NYSEBEARISH CONSENSUS
Swing · Multi-day confirmation3 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 11, 2026, 4:43 PM · Valid for ~12h
CompletedRe-run
BEARISH CONSENSUSLow Conviction
3 models· Low conviction
0 Long3 Short
Stop$515.00–$520.00
Entry$482.00–$485.00
Target$405.00–$420.00
LowConditionalHigh
BEAR (3)
BULL (0)
0%0%
Bear Case(3 models)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

SPOT is facing a perfect storm of bearish catalysts. The stock has plummeted 38.5% from its $785 52-week high, with multiple Wall Street firms slashing price targets (Key Banc cut from $830→ $720, Morgan Stanley to $775, Barclays to $650) . Technical structure is decisively bearish with "strong_bearish" signal, RSI at 45.83 showing weakening momentum, and price trapped between resistance at $515 and support at $405. The macro regime is transitioning from bull to bear (85% confidence) with credit spreads widening and flight-to-safety flows accelerating—devastating for high-beta growth stocks like SPOT (beta 1.67) . Leadership transition to co-CEOs creates execution uncertainty, while FX headwinds are expected to pressure revenue. The stock has fallen 28% YTD 2026 and shows no technical reversal pattern. At 53x P/E and 9.5x P/B with 28.9x debt-to-equity, valuation remains stretched despite the selloff, with some analysts citing fair value as low as $250.

GROK-40%

SPOT's high valuation with a PE ratio of 53.49 and PB of 9.47 makes it vulnerable in a market regime transitioning from bull to bear, as indicated by widening credit spreads and flight-to-safety in treasuries. Technical indicators show a strong bearish signal with RSI below 50 at 45.83 and SMA20 below SMA50, while the price is below key resistance at 515.12 and in a sideways trend with low volume confirmation. Mixed recent earnings, including significant misses like -0.42 vs 2.02 estimate, combined with high beta of 1.666, expose it to downside in a risk-off environment with equity/bond negative correlation.

GPT-5.20%

Technically, SPOT is failing to reclaim the key supply area/overhead volume near ~ $512– $515 (volume-profile POC and stated resistance) while momentum remains weak (RSI ~45 < 50 and MACD line deeply negative) , setting up a lower-high rejection and downside re-test. Participation is also a red flag: current volume is extremely light versus average (~5%) , suggesting recent strength lacks conviction and is vulnerable to a swift air-pocket move through lower-liquidity zones. Macro adds pressure: the regime is flagged as a transition from bull to bear with widening credit spreads and flight-to-safety signals, which typically hits high-beta growth names like SPOT hardest and can drive a move back toward the ~ $410– $405 support/52-week low region.

Bull Case(3 models)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

SPOT achieved its first full year of profitability in 2025 and recently beat earnings expectations with Q4 EPS of $3.28 vs $2.13 estimate (54% surprise). The company maintains strong institutional ownership at 68% and has demonstrated pricing power with successful price increases. Technical support exists at $405 (52-week low), providing a potential floor roughly 13% below current levels. The stock trades at a PEG ratio of 0.28, suggesting potential undervaluation relative to growth prospects.

GROK-40%

Spotify has shown strong revenue growth with 19.96 billion in revenue and recent EPS beats, such as the latest quarter at 3.28 vs estimate 2.13, indicating operational strength. The company's expansion into podcasts and personalized content could drive user engagement and subscription growth in the expanding digital audio market. With a large user base and innovative algorithms, SPOT is well-positioned to capture more market share from competitors.

GPT-5.20%

SPOT could bounce if it holds the high-volume demand zone around the volume-profile value area low (~ $410) and buyers defend the higher low structure above the $405 52-week low. The stock is still well off its 52-week high but has room to mean-revert upward toward the volume POC near ~ $512 if risk appetite improves and credit conditions stabilize. Any incremental positive company news or a broader communication-services rotation could squeeze shorts given SPOT’s beta (~1.67) .

What Would Invalidate
  • Close above $515.12 resistance would invalidate the bearish technical structure and signal potential trend reversal. Additionally, if the market regime shifts back to risk-on with VIX collapsing below 15 and credit spreads tightening, the macro headwind thesis would be compromised.
  • Daily close above $520 (regaining and holding above the $512–$515 resistance/POC zone) would invalidate the short thesis.
  • Close above resistance at 515.12 on daily chart
Grok-4Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
2.36R·78% confidence
Entry
$483.00
Target
$405.00
Stop
$516.00

SPOT's high valuation with a PE ratio of 53.49 and PB of 9.47 makes it vulnerable in a market regime transitioning from bull to bear, as indicated by widening credit spreads and flight-to-safety in treasuries. Technical indicators show a strong bearish signal with RSI below 50 at 45.83 and SMA20 below SMA50, while the price is below key resistance at 515.12 and in a sideways trend with low volume confirmation. Mixed recent earnings, including significant misses like -0.42 vs 2.02 estimate, combined with high beta of 1.666, expose it to downside in a risk-off environment with equity/bond negative correlation.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 78%Δ 8%Bull 70%
Bear Case

SPOT's high valuation with a PE ratio of 53.49 and PB of 9.47 makes it vulnerable in a market regime transitioning from bull to bear, as indicated by widening credit spreads and flight-to-safety in treasuries. Technical indicators show a strong bearish signal with RSI below 50 at 45.83 and SMA20 below SMA50, while the price is below key resistance at 515.12 and in a sideways trend with low volume confirmation. Mixed recent earnings, including significant misses like -0.42 vs 2.02 estimate, combined with high beta of 1.666, expose it to downside in a risk-off environment with equity/bond negative correlation.

Bull Case

Spotify's fundamentals show strong growth potential with a low PEG ratio of 0.28 indicating undervaluation relative to growth, supported by recent EPS beats like 3.28 vs estimate 2.13 and robust revenue of over $19 billion. Technically, the RSI is rising at 45.83, suggesting building momentum for an upside move, while the price is 19.2% above key support at $405 and within Bollinger Bands, positioning for a potential breakout towards resistance at $515. With no immediate negative catalysts and a sideways trend, this sets up for a swing long as market transitions could stabilize, allowing SPOT to capitalize on its strong position in the streaming industry.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (78% vs 70%).

3m 57s18 tools
Claude Sonnet 4.5Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORTLEANING
1.88R·78% confidence
Entry
$482.00
Target
$420.00
Stop
$515.00

SPOT is facing a perfect storm of bearish catalysts. The stock has plummeted 38.5% from its $785 52-week high, with multiple Wall Street firms slashing price targets (Key Banc cut from $830→ $720, Morgan Stanley to $775, Barclays to $650) . Technical structure is decisively bearish with "strong_bearish" signal, RSI at 45.83 showing weakening momentum, and price trapped between resistance at $515 and support at $405. The macro regime is transitioning from bull to bear (85% confidence) with credit spreads widening and flight-to-safety flows accelerating—devastating for high-beta growth stocks like SPOT (beta 1.67) . Leadership transition to co-CEOs creates execution uncertainty, while FX headwinds are expected to pressure revenue. The stock has fallen 28% YTD 2026 and shows no technical reversal pattern. At 53x P/E and 9.5x P/B with 28.9x debt-to-equity, valuation remains stretched despite the selloff, with some analysts citing fair value as low as $250.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 78%Δ 3%Bull 75%
Bear Case

SPOT is facing a perfect storm of bearish catalysts. The stock has plummeted 38.5% from its $785 52-week high, with multiple Wall Street firms slashing price targets (Key Banc cut from $830→ $720, Morgan Stanley to $775, Barclays to $650) . Technical structure is decisively bearish with "strong_bearish" signal, RSI at 45.83 showing weakening momentum, and price trapped between resistance at $515 and support at $405. The macro regime is transitioning from bull to bear (85% confidence) with credit spreads widening and flight-to-safety flows accelerating—devastating for high-beta growth stocks like SPOT (beta 1.67) . Leadership transition to co-CEOs creates execution uncertainty, while FX headwinds are expected to pressure revenue. The stock has fallen 28% YTD 2026 and shows no technical reversal pattern. At 53x P/E and 9.5x P/B with 28.9x debt-to-equity, valuation remains stretched despite the selloff, with some analysts citing fair value as low as $250.

Bull Case

SPOT presents a compelling long setup driven by multiple catalysts: Goldman Sachs just upgraded to "Buy" with expectations of 80-100 bps gross margin expansion, validating the recent $1 price hike to $12.99/month. The last two earnings reports crushed estimates by +54% and +21%, demonstrating operational momentum. Technically, SPOT is trading just 6.3% below resistance at $515 with RSI at 45.83 showing room to run, while the PEG ratio of 0.28 indicates the stock is massively undervalued relative to growth. The 1.94:1 reward-to-risk setup with clear resistance target at $515 offers an asymmetric opportunity as pricing power and margin expansion drive re-rating.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (78% vs 75%).

2m 25s28 tools
GPT-5.2Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORTLEANING
2.14R·68% confidence
Entry
$485.00
Target
$410.00
Stop
$520.00

SHORT SPOT on a rejection below the $512– $515 overhead volume/resistance zone with weak momentum and low participation, targeting a re-test of the $410– $405 support area in a worsening risk-off/credit-spread environment.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 68%Δ 6%Bull 62%
Bear Case

Technically, SPOT is failing to reclaim the key supply area/overhead volume near ~ $512– $515 (volume-profile POC and stated resistance) while momentum remains weak (RSI ~45 < 50 and MACD line deeply negative) , setting up a lower-high rejection and downside re-test. Participation is also a red flag: current volume is extremely light versus average (~5%) , suggesting recent strength lacks conviction and is vulnerable to a swift air-pocket move through lower-liquidity zones. Macro adds pressure: the regime is flagged as a transition from bull to bear with widening credit spreads and flight-to-safety signals, which typically hits high-beta growth names like SPOT hardest and can drive a move back toward the ~ $410– $405 support/52-week low region.

Bull Case

SPOT is setting up for a swing rebound as momentum stabilizes: the 4h RSI is sub-50 but rising, and price is holding well above the key demand zone near ~$405–$410 (52-week low/value-area low), suggesting sellers are losing control rather than accelerating downside. The volume profile shows price sitting just below major high-volume acceptance (HVNs around ~$492–$512 with POC ~$512); a push back through that band often leads to rotation toward the upper value area and prior supply near the mid-$540s to mid-$550s. Fundamentally, Spotify has meaningful profitability momentum (positive EPS, ~8% profit margin, ~23% ROE) and a low PEG (~0.28) that supports the market paying up for growth if risk appetite doesn’t deteriorate further.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (68% vs 62%).

2m 53s32 tools
SPOT Analysis | TradeHorde