PFE

NYSEBEARISH CONSENSUS
All Horizons · Multi-timeframe synthesis3 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 11, 2026, 12:34 PM · Valid for ~48h
CompletedRe-run
BEARISH CONSENSUSLow Conviction
2 models· 2/2 aligned — 1 abstained*
0 Long2 Short1 Skip
Stop$28.10–$28.40
Entry$27.50–$27.61
Target$25.26–$25.63
LowConditionalHigh
BEAR (2)
BULL (0)
0%1 skip0%
Bear Case(3 models)
Claude-Haiku-4.50%

PFE is at resistance ( $27.73 52-week high) with price above upper Bollinger Band showing overbought conditions, while volume weakens to 75% of average—classic exhaustion setup. Macro regime is transitioning from bull to bear (85% confidence) with credit spreads widening, flight-to-safety into treasuries/yen, and VIX complacency masking underlying stress; PFE will likely participate in equity selloff despite defensive classification. Fundamental deterioration is evident: debt-to-equity of 66.53x is dangerously high, ROE of 8.58% is weak, and PEG ratio negative suggests earnings growth is slowing; the law of large numbers suggests the streak of 15-38% beats is unsustainable, creating April 2026 earnings disappointment risk within the swing horizon. </an Thesis> <parameter name="risks">["April 2026 earnings could surprise to upside again, extending the beat streak and invalidating the exhaustion thesis", "Broader healthcare sector strength or FDA approval catalysts for PFE pipeline could trigger short squeeze and stop-loss hit", "Credit conditions could stabilize before the regime shift fully materializes, allowing equities to recover and PFE to hold resistance", "High institutional ownership (68%) and low short interest (2.28%) means limited short squeeze risk but also suggests smart money still comfortable holding"]

GPT-4o0%

Pfizer's stock is currently overbought, trading above the upper Bollinger Band, and nearing its 52-week high, suggesting a potential pullback. The technical indicators show a bearish signal with the SMA20 below the SMA50. Additionally, the overall market regime is transitioning from bull to bear, characterized by widening credit spreads and a flight-to-safety in treasuries and yen, which could put downward pressure on Pfizer's stock.

Gemini-3-Flash

PFE is currently testing major 52-week resistance at $27.73 while trading above its upper Bollinger Band, signaling a highly overbought condition ripe for a reversal. Fundamentally, the company faces

Bull Case(3 models)
Claude-Haiku-4.50%

PFE has delivered exceptional earnings beats for four consecutive quarters (15-38% above estimates), demonstrating operational excellence and strong cash generation. The company maintains a solid dividend profile and defensive positioning within healthcare, with beta of 0.441 providing relative downside protection. Forward P/E of 9.76x suggests reasonable valuation for a mature pharma company with established revenue base of $63.6B and consistent market presence across oncology, vaccines, and internal medicine.

GPT-4o0%

Pfizer's recent earnings have consistently exceeded expectations, with substantial positive earnings surprises in the past few quarters. The company's strategic acquisitions and advancements in oncology and other therapies indicate strong future growth potential. Furthermore, Pfizer's strong global presence and innovative pipeline, especially in emerging markets, provide a solid foundation for long-term revenue generation.

Gemini-3-Flash

Pfizer is demonstrating strong fundamental momentum with four consecutive quarters of significant earnings beats, most recently surpassing estimates by nearly 16%. The company is successfully pivoting

What Would Invalidate
  • Close above $28.40 with volume confirmation (>60M shares) would invalidate the short thesis, indicating buyers absorbed weakness and resistance is broken to upside.
  • Close above $28.10
Claude Haiku 4.5FastALIGNED
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
2.49R·80% confidence
Entry
$27.50
Target
$25.26
Stop
$28.40

PFE has delivered exceptional earnings beats for four consecutive quarters (15-38% above estimates), demonstrating operational excellence and strong cash generation. The company maintains a solid dividend profile and defensive positioning within healthcare, with beta of 0.441 providing relative downside protection. Forward P/E of 9.76x suggests reasonable valuation for a mature pharma company with established revenue base of $63.6B and consistent market presence across oncology, vaccines, and internal medicine.

Across timeframes
DAY
SHORT
72% · LEANING
SWING
SHORT
72% · HIGH_DELTA
POSITION
SHORT
72% · LEANING
Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 72%Δ 4%Bull 68%
Bear Case

PFE exhibits classic overbought technical setup with price above upper Bollinger Band at resistance ( $27.73) , SMA20 < SMA50 bearish crossover, and deteriorating volume (75% of average) confirming momentum divergence. More critically, the dividend is unsustainable at 126% payout ratio ( $1.72 annual dividend vs. $1.36 EPS) , creating inevitable cut risk within 12-18 months that will trigger dividend investor exodus. The macro regime is transitioning to risk-off with widening credit spreads—exactly the environment that pressures high-dividend, high-debt healthcare stocks. Patent cliffs (~ $1.5B revenue headwind) , debt-to-equity of 66.5x, and 2026 guidance under $3 EPS signal limited upside and high financial stress.

Bull Case

PFE is testing 52-week resistance at $27.73 with strong positive momentum (RSI 64.14, rising MACD) and exceptional fundamental support: forward P/E of 9.76 is heavily discounted, and the company has beaten EPS estimates for 4 consecutive quarters averaging +31.5% surprise. The conservative 2026 guidance (< $3 EPS) creates a low bar for future beats. Critically, PFE's low beta (0.441) and defensive healthcare positioning align perfectly with the current risk-off macro regime (widening credit spreads, flight-to-safety) , making it an ideal defensive play. The Phase 2b obesity pipeline success ( $28.06 analyst target) provides multi-year growth narrative, and institutional smart money is positioning for volatility/reversal, suggesting conviction among sophisticated investors.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (72% vs 68%).

1m 37s87 tools$
Gemini 3 FlashFastBALANCED
Analysis Outcome
NO TRADE

No clear edge across timeframes

Across timeframes
DAY
BALANCED
0% · CONTESTED
SWING
BALANCED
0% · CONTESTED
POSITION
BALANCED
0% · CONTESTED
Bull/Bear CompetitionBALANCED
Bull 72%Δ 0%Bear 72%
Bull Case

Pfizer is demonstrating strong relative strength, trading near its 52-week high of $27.73 and significantly above its SMA 20/50 ( $26.68) , signaling a powerful momentum breakout. The stock serves as a premier defensive play in the current 'risk-off' market transition, bolstered by a high dividend yield of ~6.3% and a low beta of 0.44, making it a primary target for flight-to-safety capital. Additionally, positive sentiment surrounding its oncology pipeline (ADCETRIS) and obesity drug developments provides the fundamental catalyst needed to clear immediate overhead resistance.

Bear Case

PFE is currently testing major 52-week resistance at $27.73 while trading above its upper Bollinger Band, indicating a severely overbought condition on the daily timeframe. The volume profile reveals a 'low volume vacuum' at current levels ($27.61), with the Point of Control (POC) significantly lower at $25.63, suggesting a lack of structural support if a reversal begins. Furthermore, the broader market regime is transitioning from bull to bear with widening credit spreads, which typically pressures pharmaceutical stocks that have recently outperformed as defensive plays.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition CONTESTED: BULL case (72%) vs BEAR case (72%) - confidence delta (0%) below threshold. Trade skipped due to insufficient conviction.

1m 01s65 tools$$
GPT-4oFastALIGNED
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
4.04R·63% confidence
Entry
$27.61
Target
$25.63
Stop
$28.10

Pfizer's recent earnings have consistently exceeded expectations, with substantial positive earnings surprises in the past few quarters. The company's strategic acquisitions and advancements in oncology and other therapies indicate strong future growth potential. Furthermore, Pfizer's strong global presence and innovative pipeline, especially in emerging markets, provide a solid foundation for long-term revenue generation.

Across timeframes
DAY
SHORT
75% · LEANING
SWING
SHORT
78% · DECIDED
POSITION
SHORT
75% · LEANING
Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 75%Δ 5%Bull 70%
Bear Case

PFE is currently trading near its resistance level at $27.73, with technical indicators suggesting overbought conditions as the price is above the upper Bollinger Band. The broader market regime is transitioning from bull to bear, indicated by credit spread widening and a flight-to-safety in treasuries, suggesting potential downward pressure on equities. Furthermore, concerns about dividend sustainability and flat forward guidance contribute to a cautious outlook. The volume profile shows low resistance above current prices, indicating a lack of support if selling pressure increases.

Bull Case

Pfizer (PFE) is positioned for potential growth due to its strategic focus on expanding into the obesity treatment market, with promising mid stage data on a monthly obesity injection. This could drive future revenue growth, compensating for declines inC OVID related product revenue. Additionally, the company's recent earnings beat expectations, which could bolster investor confidence in its near term performance. The stock is also trading near its 52 week high, suggesting potential for an upside breakout if resistance is overcome.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (75% vs 70%).

51s62 tools$
PFE Analysis | TradeHorde