LOSS-1.0%-1.0R|SHORTHigh Conviction|$149.05$150.502d 23h

XOM

NYSEBEARISH CONSENSUS
All Horizons · Multi-timeframe synthesis3 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 7, 2026, 1:50 PM · Valid for ~48h
CompletedRe-run
BEARISH CONSENSUSHigh Conviction
3 models· Strong agreement*
0 Long3 Short
Stop$150.50–$152.50
Entry$149.00–$149.05
Target$135.00–$142.35
LowConditionalHigh
BEAR (3)
BULL (0)
0%0%
Bear Case(3 models)
Claude-Opus-4.50%

XOM is extremely overbought with RSI at 80.42, testing its 52-week high at $149.57 while sitting in a low-volume node ($148.79 area shows only 13% relative volume), indicating thin air with no price acceptance at these levels. The stock trades 11% above key support and is significantly extended above the 20/50 SMA cluster at $142.35. Fundamentally, the average analyst price target of ~$131 suggests the stock is 12% overvalued at current levels, with some analysts projecting 0% annualized returns over three years due to overvaluation. Recent earnings show deteriorating momentum with the last two quarters missing estimates (-7.83% and -1.68% surprises), signaling weakening fundamentals. The oversupplied oil market backdrop and compressed refining margins pose structural headwinds, while the negative PEG ratio of -2.01 indicates expected earnings decline.

Gemini-3-Pro0%

XOM is flashing a classic technical exhaustion signal with RSI at 80.42 (extreme overbought) while slamming into major resistance at the 52-week high of $149.57. Fundamentally, the stock has decoupled from its earnings performance, having missed estimates in the last two consecutive quarters (-7.8% and -1.7% surprises), yet it trades at a premium P/E of ~22x compared to historical averages. The volume profile shows a 'low volume node' at these highs, indicating a lack of institutional commitment and high probability of rejection back toward the Value Area High around $141.

DeepSeek-R10%

Severely over bought near 52 week high with RSI divergence and weak volume confirmation. Expensivevaluation(P/E22. 2 x compounds earnings miss risks, while position in low volume node suggests limited upside persistence before mean reversion.

Bull Case(3 models)
Claude-Opus-4.50%

XOM has strong operational fundamentals with production averaging 3.0 million barrels of liquids per day and a $20 billion share buyback program supporting the stock. Recent analyst upgrades from BMO Capital ($155 target) and Mizuho ($140 target) reflect optimism about strategic acquisitions in Guyana and the company's pivot toward Carbon Capture and Storage. Geopolitical tensions have supported oil prices and refining spreads, contributing to the recent rally to 52-week highs. The company's diversification into low-carbon partnerships with BYD shows forward-thinking management adapting to energy transition.

Gemini-3-Pro0%

Momentum is undeniably strong, driven by geopolitical tensions that keep oil prices elevated and support upstream margins. Recent analyst upgrades to $155 suggest Wall Street sees room for multiple expansion, and the 'Golden Cross' (or strong alignment) of moving averages supports the immediate uptrend. A breakout above $150 could trigger a gamma squeeze or FOMO rally into blue-sky territory.

DeepSeek-R10%

X OM could extend gains if oil prices surge past 90 bbl, capitalizing on its integrated model and low debt ratio 16. 3%). Technical breakout above 150 could trigger momentum buying in this low beta defensive name.

What Would Invalidate
  • Daily close above 150.50 confirming breakout
  • A daily close above $152.50, which would clear the 52-week high resistance and psychological barriers, or a geopolitical event spiking oil >$90.
  • Daily close above $152.50 (breakout above 52-week high resistance with 2% buffer) would invalidate the mean-reversion thesis and signal a new bullish trend leg.
DeepSeek R1DeepMIXED
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
4.62R·20% confidence
Entry
$149.05
Target
$142.35
Stop
$150.50

X OM could extend gains if oil prices surge past $90/bbl, capitalizing on its integrated model and low debt ratio (16.3%) . Technical breakout above $150 could trigger momentum buying in this low beta defensive name.

Across timeframes
DAY
BALANCED
0% · contested
SWING
SHORT
68% · leaning
POSITION
BALANCED
0% · contested
Bull/Bear CompetitionBALANCED
Bear 70%Δ 2%Bull 68%
Bear Case

Technical setup shows exhaustion with RSI at 80.42 (overbought) and price at resistance with weak volume. The bearish SMA crossover (SMA20 < SMA50) confirms near-term weakness. With no immediate catalysts, the risk/reward favors shorts targeting the SMA support at $142.35 with 7:1 reward-to-risk.

Bull Case

XOM shows strong technical momentum testing resistance at $149.57 with RSI trending upward despite overbought conditions. The stock trades 4.7% above both SMAs indicating bullish momentum, while volume profile shows potential breakout above low-volume nodes. Market regime alignment with energy sector strength provides macro tailwinds for continued upside.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition CONTESTED: BULL case (68%) vs BEAR case (70%) - confidence delta (2%) below threshold. Trade skipped due to insufficient conviction.

10m 13s71 tools$
Gemini 3 ProDeepALIGNED
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
3.08R·73% confidence
Entry
$149.05
Target
$141.50
Stop
$151.50

Momentum is undeniably strong, driven by geopolitical tensions that keep oil prices elevated and support upstream margins. Recent analyst upgrades to $155 suggest Wall Street sees room for multiple expansion, and the 'Golden Cross' (or strong alignment) of moving averages supports the immediate uptrend. A breakout above $150 could trigger a gamma squeeze or FOMO rally into blue-sky territory.

Across timeframes
DAY
SHORT
75% · decided
SWING
SHORT
72% · leaning
POSITION
SHORT
72% · leaning
Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 75%Δ 7%Bull 68%
Bear Case

XOM is exhibiting a classic 'bull trap' divergence: price is pressing all-time highs ($149.05) despite a significant earnings miss (-7.8% EPS surprise) just last week. Technicals are screaming exhaustion with RSI at 80.42 (extreme overbought) and price entering a Low Volume Node, which often acts as a rejection zone. The stock is trading nearly $18 above the average analyst target ($131.84) and significantly above its Value Area High ($140.96), setting up a high-probability mean reversion event as buyers exhaust at resistance.

Bull Case

XOM is poised for a blue-sky breakout as it tests its 52-week high of $149.57, supported by recent analyst upgrades to $155 (BMO) and strategic expansion in Guyana. The stock is holding above a Low Volume Node ($148.79), suggesting price acceptance at these elevated levels, while high RSI readings confirm strong embedded momentum characteristic of genuine breakouts rather than just overbought conditions.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (75% vs 68%).

3m 37s77 tools$
Claude Opus 4.5DeepALIGNED
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
4.00R·90% confidence
Entry
$149.00
Target
$135.00
Stop
$152.50

XOM has strong operational fundamentals with production averaging 3.0 million barrels of liquids per day and a $20 billion share buyback program supporting the stock. Recent analyst upgrades from BMO Capital ($155 target) and Mizuho ($140 target) reflect optimism about strategic acquisitions in Guyana and the company's pivot toward Carbon Capture and Storage. Geopolitical tensions have supported oil prices and refining spreads, contributing to the recent rally to 52-week highs. The company's diversification into low-carbon partnerships with BYD shows forward-thinking management adapting to energy transition.

Across timeframes
DAY
SHORT
72% · decided
SWING
SHORT
72% · leaning
POSITION
SHORT
75% · decided
Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 72%Δ 10%Bull 62%
Bear Case

XOM is severely overbought with RSI at 80.42 (extreme) while testing 52-week high resistance at $149.57 - a classic exhaustion setup. The stock trades 13% ABOVE the average analyst price target of $131.84, signaling significant overextension. Volume is notably weak at only 71% of average, indicating lack of conviction in this rally. Critically, price is in a LOW VOLUME NODE at $148.79 (only 13% relative volume), suggesting thin air with no support if price reverses. The value area high is $140.96 with POC at $119.05 - price has rallied far from fair value. Oil prices remain subdued at $63-65/barrel with oversupply concerns, yet XOM has rallied as if pricing in much higher oil. The SMA20 < SMA50 (bearish crossover) confirms underlying weakness despite the price spike.

Bull Case

XOM is testing its 52-week high at $149.57 with strong momentum (RSI 80.42 rising) and a breakout pattern forming. The stock is trading at a low-volume node ($148.79 with only 13% relative volume), which typically means less resistance to price movement higher. Multiple analyst upgrades support the bullish case: BMO Capital raised its price target to $155 and Mizuho to $140. Fundamental catalysts are strong with the recent acquisition of FPSO ONE Guyana vessel expanding production capacity in the high-growth Stabroek block, plus the BYD partnership for hybrid EV innovation shows strategic diversification. Oil prices have rallied 14.37% over the past month with WTI at $63.44 and forecasted to reach $66-75 by year-end, providing tailwinds for upstream margins. The $20 billion share buyback program provides consistent demand for shares, and XOM's low beta (0.358) offers defensive characteristics in a sideways market regime. A clean break above $149.57 would trigger a new 52-week high breakout, potentially attracting momentum buyers.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (72% vs 62%).

1m 37s103 tools$
XOM Analysis | TradeHorde