LOSS-5.3%-1.0R|SHORTConditional|$470.00$495.003d 1h

SPOT

NYSEBEARISH CONSENSUS
Swing · Multi-day confirmation4 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 17, 2026, 2:44 PM · Valid for ~12h
CompletedRe-run
BEARISH CONSENSUSConditional
4 models· Moderate agreement — may need confirmation
1 Long3 Short
Stop$495.00–$515.00
Entry$470.00
Target$400.00–$420.00
LowConditionalHigh
Key Disagreement
  • Claude-Sonnet-4.5(74% LONG): "SPOT presents a compelling long setup with multiple catalysts converging: (1) **Explosive earnings momentum** - just delivered a massive 59% EPS beat ($4.43 vs $2.78 est) on Feb 10, the third consecutive quarterly beat averaging +47%, demonstrating fundamental acceleration; (2) **Technical mean reversion opportunity** - trading at $470, just 7.4% below resistance at $507 and positioned perfectly between the 20/50 SMAs, with RSI rising from oversold territory (45.04 and climbing), suggesting the post-earnings selloff has created an attractive entry; (3) **Volume profile support** - current price sits near the Point of Control at $512 with high-volume node support at $502, indicating strong institutional interest and natural price magnetism toward $512; (4) **Macro tailwinds** - market regime shows broadening participation with IWM outperformance (+1.32%) and deep VIX contango, favoring risk-on positioning in growth names, while the transition regime supports rotation into quality tech with proven earnings power; (5) **Structural profitability inflection** - gross margin expanded to 33.1% on price hikes, 751M MAUs (+11% YoY), and 290M premium subs (+10% YoY) validate the subscription model scaling, while AI integration (98M DJ users) creates new monetization vectors. The 2.1:1 reward-to-risk to POC at $512 offers asymmetric upside within the 1-3 week swing timeframe."
BEAR (3)
BULL (1)
0%0%
Bear Case(3 models)
Gemini-3-Pro0%

Despite a massive Q4 earnings beat (59% EPS surprise), SPOT has failed to hold its gains, exhibiting a classic 'sell the news' reaction. The stock is currently trading below its Volume Profile Point of Control ($512) and a massive shelf of overhead supply between $491-$512, leaving recent buyers trapped. With RSI at 45 and price struggling at $470 resistance, the inability to rally on perfect fundamental news suggests exhaustion and a likely rotation lower toward the Value Area Low ($410).

DeepSeek-R10%

Technical structure shows bearish momentum (RSI<50, SMA death cross) with strong resistance at $507. Rich valuation (P/E 36.7, P/S5.5) and recent earnings volatility create downside risk. Market rotation away from growth stocks exacerbates pressure.

GPT-5.20%

Technically, SPOT is in a weak post-run consolidation with bearish momentum signals: daily RSI ~45 (below 50) , MACD line negative, and the system flagging SMA20 < SMA50 (bearish) , suggesting rallies are more likely to be sold than sustained. Volume profile shows the point of control near ~ $512 and additional high-volume nodes around ~ $492- $502, placing current price (~ $470) below a major overhead supply zone—an area that often acts as resistance and can trigger rejection/rollover in a swing window. With no known upcoming earnings date to provide a fresh bullish catalyst, rich valuation (P/E ~36.7, EV/EBITDA ~38, P/B ~9.5) and high beta (~1.67) leave SPOT exposed to multiple compression if this week’s high-impact macro events increase rates/volatility, making a breakdown toward the ~ $410 value area low and ~ $405 support plausible.

Bull Case(4 models)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

SPOT presents a compelling long setup with multiple catalysts converging: (1) **Explosive earnings momentum** - just delivered a massive 59% EPS beat ($4.43 vs $2.78 est) on Feb 10, the third consecutive quarterly beat averaging +47%, demonstrating fundamental acceleration; (2) **Technical mean reversion opportunity** - trading at $470, just 7.4% below resistance at $507 and positioned perfectly between the 20/50 SMAs, with RSI rising from oversold territory (45.04 and climbing), suggesting the post-earnings selloff has created an attractive entry; (3) **Volume profile support** - current price sits near the Point of Control at $512 with high-volume node support at $502, indicating strong institutional interest and natural price magnetism toward $512; (4) **Macro tailwinds** - market regime shows broadening participation with IWM outperformance (+1.32%) and deep VIX contango, favoring risk-on positioning in growth names, while the transition regime supports rotation into quality tech with proven earnings power; (5) **Structural profitability inflection** - gross margin expanded to 33.1% on price hikes, 751M MAUs (+11% YoY), and 290M premium subs (+10% YoY) validate the subscription model scaling, while AI integration (98M DJ users) creates new monetization vectors. The 2.1:1 reward-to-risk to POC at $512 offers asymmetric upside within the 1-3 week swing timeframe.

Gemini-3-Pro0%

Spotify remains the undisputed leader in audio streaming with accelerating fundamentals, evidenced by 11% MAU growth and expanding margins (33.1%). The recent pullback could be viewed as a healthy consolidation within a longer-term uptrend, and if the broad market rotates back into high-quality software names, SPOT's strong free cash flow generation makes it a prime candidate for a rebound.

DeepSeek-R10%

Spot if y's market leadership in audio streaming and expanding podcast content could drive subscriber growth. Trading above SMAs suggests near term technical support, while high short interest (3.7%) creates squeeze potential if bullish catalysts emerge.

GPT-5.20%

SPOT has a fundamental tailwind from strong recent earnings execution, with the latest quarter showing a large positive EPS surprise that can keep dip-buyers engaged and support analyst upgrades/price-target raises. From a technical perspective, price is holding near its 20/50-day area (~ $468) and could grind higher in a risk-on tape toward the heavy volume node/POC around ~ $512 if macro volatility stays contained (VIX contango per regime data) . If SPOT reclaims and holds above the high-volume supply zone near $500- $512, momentum traders could chase a move toward the ~ $507- $533 resistance/value area high region.

What Would Invalidate
  • Close below $450 support (the 52-week low and key psychological level) or a decisive macro regime shift to risk-off confirmed by VIX spike above 20 with credit stress (HYG breaking below $81.50), which would invalidate the risk-on thesis underlying this swing trade.
  • Daily close above $515 (clear reclaim above the ~$507 resistance and the ~$512 volume-profile POC) invalidates the short thesis.
  • A daily close above $502, which would reclaim the Volume Point of Control and invalidate the overhead supply thesis.
Claude Sonnet 4.5Balanced
Analysis Outcome
LONGLEANING
2.10R·74% confidence
Entry
$470.00
Target
$512.00
Stop
$450.00

SPOT presents a compelling long setup with multiple catalysts converging: (1) **Explosive earnings momentum** - just delivered a massive 59% EPS beat ($4.43 vs $2.78 est) on Feb 10, the third consecutive quarterly beat averaging +47%, demonstrating fundamental acceleration; (2) **Technical mean reversion opportunity** - trading at $470, just 7.4% below resistance at $507 and positioned perfectly between the 20/50 SMAs, with RSI rising from oversold territory (45.04 and climbing), suggesting the post-earnings selloff has created an attractive entry; (3) **Volume profile support** - current price sits near the Point of Control at $512 with high-volume node support at $502, indicating strong institutional interest and natural price magnetism toward $512; (4) **Macro tailwinds** - market regime shows broadening participation with IWM outperformance (+1.32%) and deep VIX contango, favoring risk-on positioning in growth names, while the transition regime supports rotation into quality tech with proven earnings power; (5) **Structural profitability inflection** - gross margin expanded to 33.1% on price hikes, 751M MAUs (+11% YoY), and 290M premium subs (+10% YoY) validate the subscription model scaling, while AI integration (98M DJ users) creates new monetization vectors. The 2.1:1 reward-to-risk to POC at $512 offers asymmetric upside within the 1-3 week swing timeframe.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 74%Δ 6%Bear 68%
Bull Case

SPOT presents a compelling long setup with multiple catalysts converging: (1) **Explosive earnings momentum** - just delivered a massive 59% EPS beat ($4.43 vs $2.78 est) on Feb 10, the third consecutive quarterly beat averaging +47%, demonstrating fundamental acceleration; (2) **Technical mean reversion opportunity** - trading at $470, just 7.4% below resistance at $507 and positioned perfectly between the 20/50 SMAs, with RSI rising from oversold territory (45.04 and climbing), suggesting the post-earnings selloff has created an attractive entry; (3) **Volume profile support** - current price sits near the Point of Control at $512 with high-volume node support at $502, indicating strong institutional interest and natural price magnetism toward $512; (4) **Macro tailwinds** - market regime shows broadening participation with IWM outperformance (+1.32%) and deep VIX contango, favoring risk-on positioning in growth names, while the transition regime supports rotation into quality tech with proven earnings power; (5) **Structural profitability inflection** - gross margin expanded to 33.1% on price hikes, 751M MAUs (+11% YoY), and 290M premium subs (+10% YoY) validate the subscription model scaling, while AI integration (98M DJ users) creates new monetization vectors. The 2.1:1 reward-to-risk to POC at $512 offers asymmetric upside within the 1-3 week swing timeframe.

Bear Case

SPOT is exhibiting classic post-earnings exhaustion after an initial +15% spike has completely faded, with an 8.5% single-day drop signaling distribution. Price is down 40% from its 52-week high of $785, trapped in a sideways grind with strong bearish technical signals (RSI 45.04, SMA 20<SMA 50) . The stock failed to hold resistance at $507 and is now vulnerable to a retest of support at $405 (-13.6% downside) . Volume profile shows current price is BELOW the POC of $512 and all high-volume nodes, indicating weak positioning. The transition market regime with rising credit stress and defensive rotation (gold +2.49%, flight-to-safety flows) creates headwinds for high-beta growth stocks (SPOT beta 1.666) . Valuation remains stretched at 36.7x P/E despite the selloff, and the next earnings catalyst is months away, removing near-term upside drivers.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (74% vs 68%).

1m 56s31 tools
GPT-5.2Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
1.56R·64% confidence
Entry
$470.00
Target
$400.00
Stop
$515.00

SHORT SPOT: bearish momentum under overhead supply (POC ~ $512) with valuation/macro-event downside skew; target a move back toward ~ $400 while risking above $515.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 64%Δ 2%Bull 62%
Bear Case

Technically, SPOT is in a weak post-run consolidation with bearish momentum signals: daily RSI ~45 (below 50) , MACD line negative, and the system flagging SMA20 < SMA50 (bearish) , suggesting rallies are more likely to be sold than sustained. Volume profile shows the point of control near ~ $512 and additional high-volume nodes around ~ $492- $502, placing current price (~ $470) below a major overhead supply zone—an area that often acts as resistance and can trigger rejection/rollover in a swing window. With no known upcoming earnings date to provide a fresh bullish catalyst, rich valuation (P/E ~36.7, EV/EBITDA ~38, P/B ~9.5) and high beta (~1.67) leave SPOT exposed to multiple compression if this week’s high-impact macro events increase rates/volatility, making a breakdown toward the ~ $410 value area low and ~ $405 support plausible.

Bull Case

Spotify has a fresh fundamental tailwind from its latest earnings beat (EPS 4.43 vs 2.78 est.) and follow-through bullish sentiment/analyst targets, which can support multiple expansion and renewed momentum over the next 1–3 weeks. Macro conditions are not overtly risk-off (VIX term structure in contango; regime recommendation is long-bias) , which typically helps high-beta growth names like SPOT. Technically, price is holding slightly above the daily SMA 20/50 cluster (~467.7) with a rising RSI trend, suggesting a basing attempt that can mean-revert back toward the prior supply zone near $507– $533 (resistance + volume-value area) .

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (64% vs 62%).

2m 53s34 tools
DeepSeek R1Deep
Analysis Outcome
SHORTLEANING
1.35R·70% confidence
Entry
$470.00
Target
$420.00
Stop
$507.00

Technical structure shows bearish momentum (RSI<50, SMA death cross) with strong resistance at $507. Rich valuation (P/E36.7, P/S5.5) and recent earnings volatility create downside risk. Market rotation away from growth stocks exacerbates pressure.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 70%Δ 5%Bull 65%
Bear Case

Technical structure shows bearish momentum (RSI<50, SMA death cross) with strong resistance at $507. Rich valuation (P/E36.7, P/S5.5) and recent earnings volatility create downside risk. Market rotation away from growth stocks exacerbates pressure.

Bull Case

SPOT shows bullish technical positioning above key SMAs with rising RSI momentum. Fundamental strength is evidenced by 11 MAU growth, record33.1 gross margins, and successful A I feature adoption by 98 M users. Volume profile identifies clear accumulation at $512.21 (POC) , providing a technical target aligned with market leadership positioning.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (70% vs 65%).

8m 07s24 tools
Gemini 3 ProDeep
Analysis Outcome
SHORTLEANING
2.40R·72% confidence
Entry
$470.00
Target
$410.00
Stop
$495.00

Despite a massive Q4 earnings beat (59% EPS surprise), SPOT has failed to hold its gains, exhibiting a classic 'sell the news' reaction. The stock is currently trading below its Volume Profile Point of Control ($512) and a massive shelf of overhead supply between $491-$512, leaving recent buyers trapped. With RSI at 45 and price struggling at $470 resistance, the inability to rally on perfect fundamental news suggests exhaustion and a likely rotation lower toward the Value Area Low ($410).

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 72%Δ 4%Bull 68%
Bear Case

Despite a massive Q4 earnings beat (59% EPS surprise), SPOT has failed to hold its gains, exhibiting a classic 'sell the news' reaction. The stock is currently trading below its Volume Profile Point of Control ($512) and a massive shelf of overhead supply between $491-$512, leaving recent buyers trapped. With RSI at 45 and price struggling at $470 resistance, the inability to rally on perfect fundamental news suggests exhaustion and a likely rotation lower toward the Value Area Low ($410).

Bull Case

SPOT presents a compelling mean-reversion opportunity after reclaiming the converged SMA20 and SMA50 at $467, turning previous resistance into support. Following a massive 59% earnings beat (EPS $4.43 vs $2.78) and management's confident 'Year of Raising Ambition' outlook, the stock is poised to fill the gap toward the Volume Point of Control at $512. Rising RSI and a hold of the Bollinger Band midline ($452) confirm stabilizing momentum.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (72% vs 68%).

3m 00s26 tools
SPOT Analysis | TradeHorde