LLY

NYSEBULLISH
Swing · Multi-day confirmation1 Model · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 5, 2026, 4:10 PM · Valid for ~12h
CompletedRe-run
BULLISH
Analysis by Claude Sonnet 4.5· 6% edge — bull case stronger
Target$1114
Entry$1028
Stop$993.00
LowConditionalHigh
BULL (1)
BEAR (0)
0%0%
Bull Case(1 model)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

LLY presents a compelling LONG opportunity following its massive earnings beat (February 4th: EPS $1.35 vs $1.32 est, +2.27% surprise; October 30th: EPS $7.02 vs $5.89 est, +19.19% surprise). The company's GLP-1 franchise is accelerating with revenue beating forecasts by 9.5% and profit growth surging 120%, while competitor Novo Nordisk faces Medicare headwinds. Recent news shows stock surged 10%+ to $1,107 post-earnings, with analyst price targets raised to $1,161 (Guggenheim) and consensus at $1,113. Technically, price at $1,028 sits just 3.5% above support at $994 with resistance at $1,114 offering 8.4% upside. The $3 billion Netherlands manufacturing expansion and FDA Breakthrough Therapy designation for sofetabart mipitecan demonstrate robust pipeline momentum. RSI at 47.57 is rising from neutral territory, suggesting momentum inflection, while the stock trades 65% above its 52-week low of $624, confirming a strong secular uptrend in the obesity/diabetes mega-trend.

Bear Case(1 model)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

Despite strong fundamentals, LLY faces immediate technical and macro headwinds. The 4h chart shows "strong_bearish" signal with SMA20 = SMA50 at $1,041, indicating consolidation near resistance after the post-earnings spike. Price has pulled back -7.7% from resistance at $1,114 and sits -9.3% from the 52-week high of $1,134, suggesting potential distribution after the earnings-driven rally. The broader market regime is "transition_bull_to_bear" with 85% confidence, featuring credit spread widening (HYG underperforming LQD), negative equity-bond correlation (risk-off), and commodity liquidation—all classic early-stage risk-off signals that pressure high-valuation mega-caps. At a trailing P/E of 52x (even with forward P/E at 32x), LLY remains expensive and vulnerable to multiple compression if the macro environment deteriorates. Volume at only 6% of average (189k vs 3.2M avg) suggests lack of conviction in current price action.

What Would Invalidate
  • Close below support at $993 on the daily chart, which would breach the recent consolidation range and suggest the post-earnings rally has failed, potentially triggering a deeper retracement toward the $950 level or lower.
Claude Sonnet 4.5Balanced
Analysis Outcome
LONG
2.46R·78% confidence
Entry
$1028.00
Target
$1114.00
Stop
$993.00

LLY presents a compelling LONG opportunity following its massive earnings beat (February 4th: EPS $1.35 vs $1.32 est, +2.27% surprise; October 30th: EPS $7.02 vs $5.89 est, +19.19% surprise). The company's GLP-1 franchise is accelerating with revenue beating forecasts by 9.5% and profit growth surging 120%, while competitor Novo Nordisk faces Medicare headwinds. Recent news shows stock surged 10%+ to $1,107 post-earnings, with analyst price targets raised to $1,161 (Guggenheim) and consensus at $1,113. Technically, price at $1,028 sits just 3.5% above support at $994 with resistance at $1,114 offering 8.4% upside. The $3 billion Netherlands manufacturing expansion and FDA Breakthrough Therapy designation for sofetabart mipitecan demonstrate robust pipeline momentum. RSI at 47.57 is rising from neutral territory, suggesting momentum inflection, while the stock trades 65% above its 52-week low of $624, confirming a strong secular uptrend in the obesity/diabetes mega-trend.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 78%Δ 6%Bear 72%
Bull Case

LLY presents a compelling LONG opportunity following its massive earnings beat (February 4th: EPS $1.35 vs $1.32 est, +2.27% surprise; October 30th: EPS $7.02 vs $5.89 est, +19.19% surprise). The company's GLP-1 franchise is accelerating with revenue beating forecasts by 9.5% and profit growth surging 120%, while competitor Novo Nordisk faces Medicare headwinds. Recent news shows stock surged 10%+ to $1,107 post-earnings, with analyst price targets raised to $1,161 (Guggenheim) and consensus at $1,113. Technically, price at $1,028 sits just 3.5% above support at $994 with resistance at $1,114 offering 8.4% upside. The $3 billion Netherlands manufacturing expansion and FDA Breakthrough Therapy designation for sofetabart mipitecan demonstrate robust pipeline momentum. RSI at 47.57 is rising from neutral territory, suggesting momentum inflection, while the stock trades 65% above its 52-week low of $624, confirming a strong secular uptrend in the obesity/diabetes mega-trend.

Bear Case

LLY is trading at a P/E ratio of 53x with market cap near $1 trillion, representing extreme valuation even after cooling from 100+ P/E in 2023 - the stock is 9.3% below its 52-week high of $1,134 and showing clear technical weakness with strong bearish signals (RSI 47.57, price below both SMAs, MACD negative). The macro regime is transitioning from bull to bear with 85% confidence, showing credit stress, negative equity-bond correlation, and flight-to-quality into Treasuries - this risk-off environment is toxic for high-beta mega-cap growth stocks trading at nosebleed valuations. Most critically, volume is collapsing at only 6% of average (189k vs 3.2M average), suggesting the post-earnings rally to $1,107 was on extremely thin liquidity and vulnerable to reversal. With resistance at $1,114 overhead and support breaking down toward $994, the technical setup favors a move back toward the $900 level as profit-taking accelerates.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (78% vs 72%).

2m 16s31 tools
LLY Analysis | TradeHorde