OPENLONGLow Conviction3 models|
0% to target
View in Radar →

STNG

NYSEBULLISH CONSENSUS
Swing · Multi-day confirmation3 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Mar 11, 2026, 1:36 PM · Valid for ~12h
CompletedRe-run
BULLISH CONSENSUSLow Conviction
3 models· Low conviction
3 Long0 Short
Target$81.00–$83.50
Entry$74.30–$75.29
Stop$69.50–$71.71
LowConditionalHigh
Bull Case(3 models)
100%

All three models agree that STNG is the primary beneficiary of the Strait of Hormuz closure, which has removed 20% of global oil supply and driven Brent toward $110/bbl, creating a massive demand surge for longer-haul tanker routes. This macro tailwind is supported by five consecutive earnings beats and a valuation characterized by a 10.7x P/E and a PEG ratio of 0.13, which suggests growth is severely underpriced. Analysts from B. Riley, Evercore, and BTIG maintain targets between $80-$90, supported by a recent dividend hike to $0.45/share and strategic fleet modernization that enhances cash flow stability.

Bear Case(3 models)
0%

All three models highlight significant technical weakness, noting that the price has fallen below the SMA20 and SMA50 with a declining RSI of 45.23, signaling a 'strong bearish' short-term regime. There is a consensus that the stock is vulnerable to profit-taking after a 142% rally from its 52-week low, especially if diplomatic resolutions in the Middle East cause the energy risk premium to evaporate. Unique risks include a high debt-to-equity ratio of 19.4x and a contrarian 'Sell' rating from Bank of America with a $61 price target, implying 19% downside if shipping rates normalize.

What Would Invalidate
  • A daily close below the $71.29–$71.71 support zone (Point of Control/high-volume node), particularly on above-average volume, would signal a structural breakdown.
  • A diplomatic breakthrough or the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz would invalidate the bullish thesis by eliminating the primary supply shock catalyst.
Claude Opus 4.5Deep
Analysis Outcome
LONG
1.64R·64% confidence
Entry
$75.29
Target
$81.50
Stop
$71.50

STNG is a prime beneficiary of the Strait of Hormuz closure, which has removed 20% of global oil supply and is driving Brent toward $110/bbl. The Research Desk has flagged STNG as a BULLISH theme play, noting that tanker market dislocation from Gulf routes creates longer haul requirements that raise day-rates and tighten available tonnage. The company has beaten earnings estimates for 5 consecutive quarters (most recently $1.62 vs $1.53 estimate, +5.88% surprise) and increased its dividend to $0.45/share. Fundamentally, STNG is attractively valued with a P/E of 10.7, PEG ratio of 0.13, and 37% profit margin. Multiple analysts have Buy ratings with price targets of $80-90 (B. Riley at $90, Evercore/Deutsche Bank at $83) . The stock is trading near the value area high ( $79.99) with strong support at the POC ( $71.29) , and the energy supply shock provides a powerful macro catalyst that should drive product tanker rates higher throughout the holding period.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 64%Δ 26%Bear 38%
Bull Case

STNG is a prime beneficiary of the Strait of Hormuz closure, which has removed 20% of global oil supply and is driving Brent toward $110/bbl. The Research Desk has flagged STNG as a BULLISH theme play, noting that tanker market dislocation from Gulf routes creates longer haul requirements that raise day-rates and tighten available tonnage. The company has beaten earnings estimates for 5 consecutive quarters (most recently $1.62 vs $1.53 estimate, +5.88% surprise) and increased its dividend to $0.45/share. Fundamentally, STNG is attractively valued with a P/E of 10.7, PEG ratio of 0.13, and 37% profit margin. Multiple analysts have Buy ratings with price targets of $80-90 (B. Riley at $90, Evercore/Deutsche Bank at $83) . The stock is trading near the value area high ( $79.99) with strong support at the POC ( $71.29) , and the energy supply shock provides a powerful macro catalyst that should drive product tanker rates higher throughout the holding period.

Bear Case

STNG has pulled back 8% from its 52-week high of $81.85 and is now trading below both its 20-day and 50-day SMAs with RSI at 45.23 and falling momentum. The technical signal is "strong_bearish" with price currently in a sideways trend. Bank of America maintains a Sell rating with a $61 price target, suggesting 19% downside from current levels. The forward P/E of 15.7x is significantly higher than trailing P/E of 10.7x, implying analysts expect earnings to decline. The company is selling off vessels (3 tankers announced March 10) , which could signal management believes asset values are peaking. The stock has run up significantly from its lows and may face mean reversion as the initial Hormuz crisis reaction fades.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (64% vs 38%).

3m 32s31 tools
Claude Sonnet 4.5Balanced
Analysis Outcome
LONG
2.17R·72% confidence
Entry
$74.50
Target
$81.00
Stop
$71.50

STNG is a direct beneficiary of the historic Strait of Hormuz closure that has removed 20% of global oil supply and driven Brent to $110/bbl. Research desk confirms tanker market is experiencing massive demand surge as longer routes and product dislocation require more available tonnage, driving day-rates higher. This macro tailwind is supported by exceptional fundamentals: 5 consecutive earnings beats (most recent Q4 beat by 5.88%, EPS $1.62 vs $1.53) , increased dividend to $0.45/share, attractive valuation at 10.7x P/E with 36.7% profit margins, and PEG ratio of just 0.13 indicating growth is severely underpriced. Technically, price at $74.26 sits just above key support at $71.71 with clear resistance at $81.85, providing excellent risk/reward. Analysts maintain bullish targets: B. Riley at $90, Evercore/Deutsche at $83, BTIG at $80. The company's strategic fleet optimization (recent vessel sales + time charter agreements) positions it to capture maximum value from this unprecedented energy supply shock.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 72%Δ 14%Bear 58%
Bull Case

STNG is a direct beneficiary of the historic Strait of Hormuz closure that has removed 20% of global oil supply and driven Brent to $110/bbl. Research desk confirms tanker market is experiencing massive demand surge as longer routes and product dislocation require more available tonnage, driving day-rates higher. This macro tailwind is supported by exceptional fundamentals: 5 consecutive earnings beats (most recent Q4 beat by 5.88%, EPS $1.62 vs $1.53) , increased dividend to $0.45/share, attractive valuation at 10.7x P/E with 36.7% profit margins, and PEG ratio of just 0.13 indicating growth is severely underpriced. Technically, price at $74.26 sits just above key support at $71.71 with clear resistance at $81.85, providing excellent risk/reward. Analysts maintain bullish targets: B. Riley at $90, Evercore/Deutsche at $83, BTIG at $80. The company's strategic fleet optimization (recent vessel sales + time charter agreements) positions it to capture maximum value from this unprecedented energy supply shock.

Bear Case

STNG has already rallied 25% into February earnings and is now showing technical exhaustion with strong bearish signals (RSI 45.23 falling, price -4.3% below both SMA20 and SMA50). The stock rejected resistance at $81.85 and is pulling back with decreasing momentum. The Hormuz crisis is priced in - the stock surged on the initial news but is now profit-taking. Valuation is stretched at 10.7x P/E with extreme debt-to-equity of 19.4x, making the company vulnerable if tanker rates normalize. Bank of America maintains a Sell rating with $61 target, and the recent -2.58% drop signals institutional distribution after the rally. Volume profile shows Point of Control at $71.29, suggesting price wants to revert lower toward fair value.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (72% vs 58%).

3m 39s32 tools
DeepSeek R1Deep
Analysis Outcome
LONG
1.83R·68% confidence
Entry
$75.29
Target
$81.85
Stop
$71.71

STNG's strategic fleet modernization (3 tankers sold + new charters) enhances cash flow stability while maintaining exposure to elevated shipping rates. With energy supply shocks boosting tanker demand, their 36.7% profit margin and 11.35% ROE position them to capitalize on market dislocation. Recent dividend increase to $0.45/share signals management confidence.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 68%Δ 3%Bear 65%
Bull Case

STNG's strategic fleet modernization (3 tankers sold + new charters) enhances cash flow stability while maintaining exposure to elevated shipping rates. With energy supply shocks boosting tanker demand, their 36.7% profit margin and 11.35% ROE position them to capitalize on market dislocation. Recent dividend increase to $0.45/share signals management confidence.

Bear Case

Technical breakdown below SMAs (77.59) confirms bearish momentum with RSI(45) showing room to oversold. Fleet sales signal peak cycle positioning while 19.36 debt/equity ratio creates refinancing risk as rates rise. Neutral macro regime lacks directional tailwinds to sustain elevated valuations at 4.15 P/S.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (68% vs 65%).

4m 26s17 tools