HIMS

NYSEBEARISH CONSENSUS
Swing · Multi-day confirmation4 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 23, 2026, 2:49 PM · Valid for ~12h
CompletedRe-run
BEARISH CONSENSUSConditional
4 models· Moderate agreement — may need confirmation
1 Long3 Short
Stop$16.85–$17.05
Entry$15.40
Target$11.25–$13.00
LowConditionalHigh
Key Disagreement
  • DeepSeek-R1(70% LONG): "HIMS presents a compelling long opportunity with extreme oversold conditions (RSI 16.27) testing strong support at $15.29. The stock trades at attractive 14.45 forward P/E with 26.2% ROE, while calm market conditions (76% confidence) favor momentum rebounds. Volume profile confirms high-volume node support at $15.77."
BEAR (3)
BULL (1)
0%0%
Bear Case(3 models)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

HIMS faces an existential regulatory and legal crisis that has destroyed 78% of its market value from the $70.43 peak. Novo Nordisk's February 9th lawsuit seeking a permanent ban on compounded GLP-1 sales, combined with FDA Commissioner Makary's "illegal copycats" warning and DOJ referral, threatens the company's primary growth engine. The stock has crashed 46.7% in one month as HIMS was forced to pull its oral semaglutide pill on Feb 7th. With earnings tonight expected to show EPS declining 81.8% YoY to just $0.02 (missing estimates in 2 of last 3 quarters including a -40% surprise in Nov 2025), and prior guidance misses creating investor caution, the company faces severe downside if guidance reflects the GLP-1 revenue loss. Technical structure shows price breaking below the POC at $16.72 with weak volume confirmation, targeting the value area low at $15.77 already breached.

Claude-Opus-4.50%

HIMS faces a perfect storm of regulatory and legal headwinds that fundamentally threaten its core GLP-1 compounding business. The FDA labeled its $49 compounded oral semaglutide pill as an "illegal copycat" (Feb 7), Novo Nordisk filed a patent infringement lawsuit (Feb 9), and new API restrictions (Feb 18) further constrain its injectable GLP-1 business. With Q4 EPS expected to collapse 81.8% YoY to just $0.02, the company's growth narrative is severely impaired. The debt-to-equity ratio of 192% is dangerously high, and despite being down 50% YTD, the stock still trades at 29.5x P/E with a broken business model. Social sentiment is bearish with the stock hitting new 52-week lows, and the technical structure shows SMA20 < SMA50 (bearish crossover) with price trading 2.9% below both moving averages. The volume profile shows current price below the Point of Control at $16.72, suggesting sellers remain in control.

GPT-5.20%

Technically, HIMS is in a broken structure: price is below key moving averages (SMA20 < SMA50 and price below both) , momentum is deteriorating (RSI trend falling) , and it is retesting the lowest support zone (~ $15.29) with little room beneath—failure here can open a fast air-pocket toward the lower Bollinger area (~ $13.4) and then the low- $12s. Fundamentally/catalyst-wise, recent reporting highlights regulatory/legal overhang tied to compounded GLP-1 products (FDA actions and a Novo Nordisk lawsuit) , and earnings have shown negative surprises in recent quarters, increasing the probability of another guidance disappointment that drives continuation selling. With high beta (~2.47) and recent collapse from the 52-week high (~-78%) , the path of least resistance remains down if support breaks and sellers defend the volume-profile POC (~ $16.72) on any bounce.

Bull Case(4 models)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

HIMS is trading at deeply oversold levels with RSI at 16.27, just 0.8% above the 52-week low of $15.29, suggesting extreme selling exhaustion and potential for a technical relief bounce. The company reports Q4 earnings today after market close with revenue expected to grow 28.7% YoY to $619M, and any positive surprise or better-than-feared guidance could trigger a sharp short squeeze given the 41.7% short interest and extreme bearish positioning. The calm market regime (76% confidence) with VIX complacency and bullish SPY momentum provides a supportive macro backdrop for risk assets to stabilize.

DeepSeek-R10%

HIMS presents a compelling long opportunity with extreme oversold conditions (RSI 16.27) testing strong support at $15.29. The stock trades at attractive 14.45 forward P/E with 26.2% ROE, while calm market conditions (76% confidence) favor momentum rebounds. Volume profile confirms high-volume node support at $15.77.

Claude-Opus-4.50%

HIMS has experienced a massive 78% drawdown from its 52-week high of $70.43, potentially creating oversold conditions for a technical bounce. The RSI at 16.27 is extremely oversold, and the stock is testing support near $15.29 which could attract dip buyers. The company's Eucalyptus acquisition ( $1.15B) represents a strategic pivot toward international diversification away from US regulatory headwinds, and if Q4 earnings tonight beat the low $0.02 EPS estimate, a short squeeze could materialize given the heavily beaten-down sentiment.

GPT-5.20%

HIMS is extremely oversold on the 4h timeframe (RSI ~16) while sitting just above major support near ~ $15.29 (52-week low) , which can trigger sharp mean-reversion rallies as shorts cover and dip-buyers step in. The broader market regime is calm/trending with a bullish tilt (VIX complacent/contango) , which can support risk-on rebounds even in damaged charts. If upcoming earnings commentary reduces GLP-1 regulatory uncertainty or the M&A pivot is framed as accretive, the stock could squeeze back toward the high-volume node/POC around ~ $16.7 and potentially the ~ $19.5 resistance area.

What Would Invalidate
  • Close above $16.90 (above SMA20 and Point of Control at $16.72) on strong volume, or a significant earnings beat that reverses the bearish narrative.
  • Close above $16.85 (SMA 20/50 confluence and POC resistance) or earnings report shows GLP-1 regulatory impact is minimal with strong forward guidance maintaining growth trajectory above 25% YoY.
  • Thesis invalid if HIMS closes above $17.05 (reclaiming above the key volume/mean area and negating the breakdown setup).
DeepSeek R1Deep
Analysis Outcome
LONG
4.91R·70% confidence
Entry
$15.42
Target
$16.50
Stop
$15.20

HIMS presents a compelling long opportunity with extreme oversold conditions (RSI 16.27) testing strong support at $15.29. The stock trades at attractive 14.45 forward P/E with 26.2% ROE, while calm market conditions (76% confidence) favor momentum rebounds. Volume profile confirms high-volume node support at $15.77.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 70%Δ 10%Bear 60%
Bull Case

HIMS presents a compelling long opportunity with extreme oversold conditions (RSI 16.27) testing strong support at $15.29. The stock trades at attractive 14.45 forward P/E with 26.2% ROE, while calm market conditions (76% confidence) favor momentum rebounds. Volume profile confirms high-volume node support at $15.77.

Bear Case

Price broke below high-volume node ( $15.77) with bearish momentum (SMA 20<SMA 50, MACD -4.29) . Fundamentals show deteriorating earnings (2 consecutive misses) , dangerous debt-to-equity (192.4%) , and negative PEG ratio. Volume at 0.12% of average confirms lack of buyers.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (70% vs 60%).

10m 24s23 tools
GPT-5.2Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
1.88R·63% confidence
Entry
$15.40
Target
$12.30
Stop
$17.05

Short breakdown continuation: fading any bounce into the $15.7– $16.7 volume area with a stop above ~ $17.05, targeting a support failure move toward the low- $12s (~3× ATR) given ongoing regulatory/legal overhang and bearish trend structure.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 63%Δ 1%Bull 62%
Bear Case

Technically, HIMS is in a broken structure: price is below key moving averages (SMA20 < SMA50 and price below both) , momentum is deteriorating (RSI trend falling) , and it is retesting the lowest support zone (~ $15.29) with little room beneath—failure here can open a fast air-pocket toward the lower Bollinger area (~ $13.4) and then the low- $12s. Fundamentally/catalyst-wise, recent reporting highlights regulatory/legal overhang tied to compounded GLP-1 products (FDA actions and a Novo Nordisk lawsuit) , and earnings have shown negative surprises in recent quarters, increasing the probability of another guidance disappointment that drives continuation selling. With high beta (~2.47) and recent collapse from the 52-week high (~-78%) , the path of least resistance remains down if support breaks and sellers defend the volume-profile POC (~ $16.72) on any bounce.

Bull Case

HIMS is at a major inflection zone: price ( $15.41) is testing the 52-week low/support at ~ $15.29 while 4h RSI is deeply oversold (16.27) , creating a high-odds mean-reversion backdrop if support holds. The volume profile shows heavy acceptance just above here (HVNs at ~ $15.77 and ~ $16.72) , which often acts as a magnet back upward after capitulation selling. Macro context is supportive for a rebound attempt (calm, bullish regime; VIX contango/complacent) , and fundamentals aren’t extreme on sales (P/S ~1.6; forward P/E ~14.5) , leaving room for re-rating if earnings/guidance reduces uncertainty around the recent regulatory headline overhang.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (63% vs 62%).

2m 54s32 tools
Claude Sonnet 4.5Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
2.86R·78% confidence
Entry
$15.40
Target
$11.25
Stop
$16.85

HIMS faces an existential regulatory and legal crisis that has destroyed 78% of its market value from the $70.43 peak. Novo Nordisk's February 9th lawsuit seeking a permanent ban on compounded GLP-1 sales, combined with FDA Commissioner Makary's "illegal copycats" warning and DOJ referral, threatens the company's primary growth engine. The stock has crashed 46.7% in one month as HIMS was forced to pull its oral semaglutide pill on Feb 7th. With earnings tonight expected to show EPS declining 81.8% YoY to just $0.02 (missing estimates in 2 of last 3 quarters including a -40% surprise in Nov 2025), and prior guidance misses creating investor caution, the company faces severe downside if guidance reflects the GLP-1 revenue loss. Technical structure shows price breaking below the POC at $16.72 with weak volume confirmation, targeting the value area low at $15.77 already breached.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 78%Δ 6%Bull 72%
Bear Case

HIMS faces an existential regulatory and legal crisis that has destroyed 78% of its market value from the $70.43 peak. Novo Nordisk's February 9th lawsuit seeking a permanent ban on compounded GLP-1 sales, combined with FDA Commissioner Makary's "illegal copycats" warning and DOJ referral, threatens the company's primary growth engine. The stock has crashed 46.7% in one month as HIMS was forced to pull its oral semaglutide pill on Feb 7th. With earnings tonight expected to show EPS declining 81.8% YoY to just $0.02 (missing estimates in 2 of last 3 quarters including a -40% surprise in Nov 2025), and prior guidance misses creating investor caution, the company faces severe downside if guidance reflects the GLP-1 revenue loss. Technical structure shows price breaking below the POC at $16.72 with weak volume confirmation, targeting the value area low at $15.77 already breached.

Bull Case

HIMS is testing critical support at $15.29 (52-week low) with RSI at deeply oversold 16.27, signaling extreme capitulation and mean-reversion setup. The stock trades at attractive valuation (P/E 29.5 vs healthcare sector, 1.6x P/S) with strong fundamentals: 26% ROE, profitable with $0.53 EPS, and $2.2B revenue in a high-growth telehealth sector. Earnings TODAY (Feb 23 after hours) provides a binary catalyst where any guidance beat or positive GLP-1 legal clarity could trigger violent short-covering rally from current -78% drawdown from highs. Volume profile shows POC at $16.72 just above current price, with high-volume node support at $15.77 - price is at institutional accumulation zone. Market regime is CALM (76% confidence) favoring trend-following, and the brutal 46.7% monthly selloff has likely flushed out weak hands, setting up a classic oversold bounce into resistance at $19.52.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (78% vs 72%).

2m 23s37 tools
Claude Opus 4.5Deep
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
1.60R·68% confidence
Entry
$15.40
Target
$13.00
Stop
$16.90

HIMS faces a perfect storm of regulatory and legal headwinds that fundamentally threaten its core GLP-1 compounding business. The FDA labeled its $49 compounded oral semaglutide pill as an "illegal copycat" (Feb 7), Novo Nordisk filed a patent infringement lawsuit (Feb 9), and new API restrictions (Feb 18) further constrain its injectable GLP-1 business. With Q4 EPS expected to collapse 81.8% YoY to just $0.02, the company's growth narrative is severely impaired. The debt-to-equity ratio of 192% is dangerously high, and despite being down 50% YTD, the stock still trades at 29.5x P/E with a broken business model. Social sentiment is bearish with the stock hitting new 52-week lows, and the technical structure shows SMA20 < SMA50 (bearish crossover) with price trading 2.9% below both moving averages. The volume profile shows current price below the Point of Control at $16.72, suggesting sellers remain in control.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 68%Δ 16%Bull 52%
Bear Case

HIMS faces a perfect storm of regulatory and legal headwinds that fundamentally threaten its core GLP-1 compounding business. The FDA labeled its $49 compounded oral semaglutide pill as an "illegal copycat" (Feb 7), Novo Nordisk filed a patent infringement lawsuit (Feb 9), and new API restrictions (Feb 18) further constrain its injectable GLP-1 business. With Q4 EPS expected to collapse 81.8% YoY to just $0.02, the company's growth narrative is severely impaired. The debt-to-equity ratio of 192% is dangerously high, and despite being down 50% YTD, the stock still trades at 29.5x P/E with a broken business model. Social sentiment is bearish with the stock hitting new 52-week lows, and the technical structure shows SMA20 < SMA50 (bearish crossover) with price trading 2.9% below both moving averages. The volume profile shows current price below the Point of Control at $16.72, suggesting sellers remain in control.

Bull Case

HIMS presents a high-risk/high-reward oversold bounce opportunity after a brutal 78% decline from its 52-week high of $70.43. The RSI at 16.27 is extremely oversold (below 30 threshold) , indicating the stock is technically stretched to the downside and due for a relief rally. The stock is testing its 52-week low ( $15.29) , a critical support level, while trading just 0.8% above this floor. The forward P/E of 14.46x is attractive for a healthcare growth company with 28.7% YoY revenue growth expected in Q4. The Eucalyptus acquisition ( $1.15B) represents a strategic pivot to international markets, diversifying away from US regulatory headwinds. The calm market regime (76% confidence) favors trend-following and momentum strategies. Volume profile shows strong high-volume nodes at $15.77- $16.72, providing a potential accumulation zone. A positive earnings surprise today could trigger a significant short squeeze given the heavily beaten-down sentiment.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (68% vs 52%).

2m 08s34 tools