OPENSHORTLow Conviction4 models|
4% to target
View in Radar →

TATAMOTORS

NSELEAN BEARISH
Swing · Multi-day confirmation4 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 25, 2026, 5:17 AM · Valid for ~12h
CompletedRe-run
LEAN BEARISH
4 models· Only 50% voted — not enough for consensus
0 Long2 Short2 Contested
Stop₹387.55–₹390.00
Entry₹377.55–₹378.50
Target₹350.00–₹355.00
LowConditionalHigh
BEAR (2)
BULL (0)
0%2 skip0%
Bear Case(4 models)
DeepSeek-R10%

Price struggles below SMA 20/50 death cross (378.72) with MACD momentum flatlining. Bearish volume profile shows weak participation (85% of avg volume) at current levels. Fundamental risks include high debt (61.55% D/E ratio) and recent EPS miss (-0.05 vs -0.01 est) . Transitional market regime favors mean-reversion plays from current resistance zone.

Claude-Opus-4.50%

TATAMOTORS faces severe structural headwinds with a leadership exodus including heads of HR, marketing, and international strategy creating management instability during the critical demerger phase. The fundamentals are deteriorating rapidly with revenue down 13.4% YoY, operating income loss of ₹8,516 crore, and the Commercial Vehicles arm reporting a ₹867 crore net loss. The stock is trading just below its SMA20 (₹378.72) with SMA20 < SMA50 confirming bearish trend structure. RSI momentum is falling despite being above 50, suggesting weakening buying pressure. The stock is testing the Point of Control at ₹378.42 and a breakdown below support at ₹371.65 would target the low volume node zone around ₹357-360. JLR concerns regarding global demand slowdowns continue to weigh on valuation, and the market regime is bearish with credit markets diverging negatively from equities.

Claude-Sonnet-4.5

TATAMOTORS faces severe operational headwinds with Q3 FY26 consolidated net loss of ₹3, 483 crores (vs ₹4, 164 crore profit YoY) , driven by JLR's cyber attack causing 50, 000 unit production loss and ₹800 crore exceptional charges. The stock has collapsed -49.3% from its 52-week high of ₹744 and is testing critical support at ₹371.65 with falling RSI trend and bearish SMA 20/SMA 50 alignment. Revenue declined 13.4% YoY while elevated marketing expenses persist in a "challenging demand environment, " and the commercial vehicles arm posted a ₹867 crore loss. Technical structure shows price trap

GPT-5.2

Technically, TATAMOTORS is failing to trend higher: the daily structure is sideways with SMA 20<SMA 50 (bearish bias) and price sitting slightly below both averages, while RSI is falling and MACD is flat—often a setup for range breakdown rather than continuation. Price is perched just above a well-defined support (~371.65) ; a clean break below that level can quickly traverse the low-volume pocket (around 360–363 per volume profile) toward the lower Bollinger area (~350) and potentially beyond. Fundamentally/sentiment-wise, recent negative headlines around losses/revenue pressure and leadershi

Bull Case(2 models)
Claude-Sonnet-4.5

TATAMOTORS presents a compelling technical support bounce opportunity at ₹377.55, sitting just 1.6% above key support at ₹371.65 and directly at the Point of Control (₹378.42) where maximum volume has traded. The RSI at 56.36 shows healthy bullish momentum without being overbought, while the stock trades within normal Bollinger Bands with 2.62% ATR suggesting manageable volatility. Fundamentally, the stock is deeply undervalued at a P/E of 6.66 (vs industry average of 15-20), trading at only 0.34x sales with strong ROE of 22.67%, and has attracted increased institutional interest with FII hold

GPT-5.2

Technicals show a constructive base: price (~₹377.6) is holding just above key support (~₹371.7) while sitting on the volume-profile point of control (~₹378.4), suggesting strong acceptance and potential for a mean-reversion push back toward the upper band/overhead supply. Momentum isn’t overheated (RSI ~56, still bullish) and ATR is ~₹9.9/day, making a move into the ₹400–₹410 zone plausible within a 1–3 week swing if support continues to hold. Fundamentally, the stock screens inexpensive (P/E ~6.7, EV/EBITDA ~4.0, P/S ~0.34) with solid ROE (~22.7%), so any stabilization in headlines can quick

What Would Invalidate
  • Daily close above ₹390 (above resistance at ₹387.50 and upper Bollinger Band region) would invalidate the bearish thesis and suggest a trend reversal.
  • Daily close above 387.55 resistance with volume >1.2x average
DeepSeek R1Deep
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
2.60R·63% confidence
Entry
₹378.50
Target
₹355.00
Stop
₹387.55

Price struggles below SMA 20/50 death cross (378.72) with MACD momentum flatlining. Bearish volume profile shows weak participation (85% of avg volume) at current levels. Fundamental risks include high debt (61.55% D/E ratio) and recent EPS miss (-0.05 vs -0.01 est) . Transitional market regime favors mean-reversion plays from current resistance zone.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 63%Δ 13%Bull 50%
Bear Case

Price struggles below SMA 20/50 death cross (378.72) with MACD momentum flatlining. Bearish volume profile shows weak participation (85% of avg volume) at current levels. Fundamental risks include high debt (61.55% D/E ratio) and recent EPS miss (-0.05 vs -0.01 est) . Transitional market regime favors mean-reversion plays from current resistance zone.

Bull Case

TATAMOTORS shows strong technical support at ₹371.65 with high-volume accumulation nodes at ₹375-378. RSI 56.36 indicates bullish momentum while avoiding overbought conditions. Fundamentally, it trades at deep discount with P/E 6.66 and P/B 1.28 versus sector, while 22.67% ROE demonstrates capital efficiency. As India's auto leader with growing EV exposure, it benefits from manufacturing tailwinds with no near-term earnings risk.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (63% vs 50%).

5m 44s19 tools
GPT-5.2Balanced
Analysis Outcome
NO TRADE0% edge
BULL
60%
BEAR
60%

Bull and bear cases balanced — no clear edge

Bull/Bear CompetitionBALANCED
Bull 60%Δ 0%Bear 60%
Bull Case

Technicals show a constructive base: price (~₹377.6) is holding just above key support (~₹371.7) while sitting on the volume-profile point of control (~₹378.4), suggesting strong acceptance and potential for a mean-reversion push back toward the upper band/overhead supply. Momentum isn’t overheated (RSI ~56, still bullish) and ATR is ~₹9.9/day, making a move into the ₹400–₹410 zone plausible within a 1–3 week swing if support continues to hold. Fundamentally, the stock screens inexpensive (P/E ~6.7, EV/EBITDA ~4.0, P/S ~0.34) with solid ROE (~22.7%), so any stabilization in headlines can quickly re-rate sentiment from “bad but priced” to “better than feared.”

Bear Case

Technically, TATAMOTORS is failing to trend higher: the daily structure is sideways with SMA 20<SMA 50 (bearish bias) and price sitting slightly below both averages, while RSI is falling and MACD is flat—often a setup for range breakdown rather than continuation. Price is perched just above a well-defined support (~371.65) ; a clean break below that level can quickly traverse the low-volume pocket (around 360–363 per volume profile) toward the lower Bollinger area (~350) and potentially beyond. Fundamentally/sentiment-wise, recent negative headlines around losses/revenue pressure and leadership churn increase downside risk and reduce dip-buying conviction, and the broader market regime is in a mild bearish “transition” with negative 5-day trend and equity-credit divergence—conditions where support breaks can follow through.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition CONTESTED: BULL case (60%) vs BEAR case (60%) - confidence delta (0%) below threshold. Trade skipped due to insufficient conviction.

2m 54s32 tools
Claude Opus 4.5Deep
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
2.21R·62% confidence
Entry
₹377.55
Target
₹350.00
Stop
₹390.00

TATAMOTORS faces severe structural headwinds with a leadership exodus including heads of HR, marketing, and international strategy creating management instability during the critical demerger phase. The fundamentals are deteriorating rapidly with revenue down 13.4% YoY, operating income loss of ₹8,516 crore, and the Commercial Vehicles arm reporting a ₹867 crore net loss. The stock is trading just below its SMA20 (₹378.72) with SMA20 < SMA50 confirming bearish trend structure. RSI momentum is falling despite being above 50, suggesting weakening buying pressure. The stock is testing the Point of Control at ₹378.42 and a breakdown below support at ₹371.65 would target the low volume node zone around ₹357-360. JLR concerns regarding global demand slowdowns continue to weigh on valuation, and the market regime is bearish with credit markets diverging negatively from equities.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 62%Δ 6%Bull 56%
Bear Case

TATAMOTORS faces severe structural headwinds with a leadership exodus including heads of HR, marketing, and international strategy creating management instability during the critical demerger phase. The fundamentals are deteriorating rapidly with revenue down 13.4% YoY, operating income loss of ₹8,516 crore, and the Commercial Vehicles arm reporting a ₹867 crore net loss. The stock is trading just below its SMA20 (₹378.72) with SMA20 < SMA50 confirming bearish trend structure. RSI momentum is falling despite being above 50, suggesting weakening buying pressure. The stock is testing the Point of Control at ₹378.42 and a breakdown below support at ₹371.65 would target the low volume node zone around ₹357-360. JLR concerns regarding global demand slowdowns continue to weigh on valuation, and the market regime is bearish with credit markets diverging negatively from equities.

Bull Case

TATAMOTORS presents a compelling technical entry near the Point of Control (₹378.42) with price currently at ₹377.55, sitting right in the high-volume node zone which historically acts as strong support. The stock is 12.5% above its 52-week low of ₹335.60 and has established a clear support base at ₹371.65, with RSI at 56.36 showing bullish momentum without being overbought. The fundamentals are exceptionally attractive with a P/E of just 6.66 (forward P/E 21.9), P/B of 1.29, and EV/EBITDA of 3.99 - all indicating significant undervaluation for a major auto manufacturer with ROE of 22.7%. The recent demerger into separate PV and CV entities could unlock value as each segment trades on its own merits. Bollinger Band positioning within bands with upside to upper band at ₹395.68 provides a clear technical target. The India banking/credit acceleration theme from research desk macro suggests a supportive domestic economic backdrop for consumer cyclicals.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (62% vs 56%).

1m 49s33 tools
Claude Sonnet 4.5Balanced
Analysis Outcome
NO TRADE0% edge
BULL
62%
BEAR
62%

Bull and bear cases balanced — no clear edge

Bull/Bear CompetitionBALANCED
Bull 62%Δ 0%Bear 62%
Bull Case

TATAMOTORS presents a compelling technical support bounce opportunity at ₹377.55, sitting just 1.6% above key support at ₹371.65 and directly at the Point of Control (₹378.42) where maximum volume has traded. The RSI at 56.36 shows healthy bullish momentum without being overbought, while the stock trades within normal Bollinger Bands with 2.62% ATR suggesting manageable volatility. Fundamentally, the stock is deeply undervalued at a P/E of 6.66 (vs industry average of 15-20), trading at only 0.34x sales with strong ROE of 22.67%, and has attracted increased institutional interest with FII holdings rising to 17.88% and MF holdings to 8.82% as of December 2025. The massive ₹76,170 crore net profit in Q2 2026, despite one-time gains, demonstrates the company's asset value and potential for operational turnaround in the commercial vehicle segment.

Bear Case

TATAMOTORS faces severe operational headwinds with Q3 FY26 consolidated net loss of ₹3, 483 crores (vs ₹4, 164 crore profit YoY) , driven by JLR's cyber attack causing 50, 000 unit production loss and ₹800 crore exceptional charges. The stock has collapsed -49.3% from its 52-week high of ₹744 and is testing critical support at ₹371.65 with falling RSI trend and bearish SMA 20/SMA 50 alignment. Revenue declined 13.4% YoY while elevated marketing expenses persist in a "challenging demand environment, " and the commercial vehicles arm posted a ₹867 crore loss. Technical structure shows price trapped between resistance at ₹387.5 and support at ₹371.65 with below-average volume (85% of normal) indicating weak buyer conviction. The macro regime is bearish/transition with credit-equity divergence signaling late-cycle warning patterns, particularly unfavorable for cyclical auto manufacturers.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition CONTESTED: BULL case (62%) vs BEAR case (62%) - confidence delta (0%) below threshold. Trade skipped due to insufficient conviction.

2m 09s36 tools