Research desk report triggered reanalysis on MPC. Verdict: HOLD (0/3 EXIT). Conviction: 62.
54% base +8 (Hormuz supply shock depth) +5 (Defensive sector rotation) -7 (Bearish macro regime) -3 (RSI approaching overbought) -5 (Premortem: Hormuz ceasefire) = 52%
50% base +15 (Hormuz crisis driving refining margins to 4-year highs) +8 (Goldman Sachs upgrade to $239 target on strong Q4 results) +7 (Research desk energy theme directly aligned with MPC refining model) -7 (RSI 68.8 near resistance at $236 with bearish regime headwind) -5 (Ceasefire announcement collapses oil premium and crack spreads compress 40%+ in 3 days) = 68%
54% base +12 (Desk Thesis: Refiner Arb) +8 (Technical/Analyst Strength) -5 (Macro Headwind) -4 (Demand Destruction Risk) = 65%