TSLA

NASDAQLEAN BEARISH
Swing · Multi-day confirmation4 Models · Analysis Snapshot: Feb 24, 2026, 2:45 PM · Valid for ~12h
CompletedRe-run
LEAN BEARISH
4 models· Only 75% voted — not enough for consensus
1 Long2 Short1 Contested
Stop$415.00–$416.00
Entry$398.00–$399.00
Target$360.00–$365.00
LowConditionalHigh
Key Disagreements
  • Split opinion: 1 model(s) LONG vs 2 model(s) SHORT
  • DeepSeek-R1(62% LONG): "TSLA shows technical stabilization near $394 support with RSI(38) approaching oversold levels. High-volume node at $419 provides intermediate upside target, while alignment with AI/tech thematic tailwinds from NVDA earnings could spark momentum. Reward-to-risk ratio of 2.14:1 offers favorable asymmetry despite bearish regime."
BEAR (2)
BULL (1)
0%1 skip0%
Bear Case(3 models)
Claude-Sonnet-4.50%

TSLA exhibits severe technical deterioration with strong bearish signals (RSI 38.31, price -3% below both SMA 20/SMA 50, -20% from 52-week highs) in a trending bearish macro regime (80% confidence) . Most recent earnings on Jan 28 missed by -31.43%, a catastrophic miss signaling fundamental deterioration. Valuation is egregious at 385x P/E and 16.3x P/S with only 4% profit margins, making it vulnerable to multiple compression. California DMV lawsuit over Autopilot deceptive marketing creates regulatory overhang, while significant insider selling ( $25.6M by Kimbal Musk) signals lack of confidence. Volume profile shows Point of Control at $435.94 far above current price, with high-volume resistance nodes at $435-439 creating a ceiling. Price is testing support at $394 with next support at $365 (low-volume node at $389) , setting up breakdown risk.

GPT-5.20%

Technically, TSLA’s 4h structure is bearish: price is below the 20/50 SMAs (~ $412) , RSI is sub-50 (38) , and the chart is in a support-test near ~ $394—if that floor breaks, the volume profile shows a low-volume zone below current price, increasing odds of a fast air-pocket drop. Macro/regime context is a bearish transition with trending character and risk-off signals (small-cap under performance, flight-to-safety flows, VIX term structure flattening) , which typically pressures high-beta growth like TSLA (beta ~1.89) and makes rallies more likely to fade. Fundamentally, valuation looks stretched (P/E ~385, forward P/E ~147, EV/EBITDA ~144) with low profit margin (~4%) , leaving the stock vulnerable to multiple compression if sentiment deteriorates, while news flow includes regulatory/legal overhang and robotaxi safety concerns that can re-rate the narrative lower.

Claude-Opus-4.5

TSLA presents a compelling short setup with multiple converging bearish factors. Technically, the stock shows a "strong_bearish" signal with price trading below both SMA20 ( $412) and SMA50 ( $412) , MACD deeply negative at -5.44, and a "support_test" pattern that suggests breakdown risk. The volume profile reveals price is near low-volume nodes ( $389- $392) , meaning if support at $394 breaks, there's minimal volume support until significantly lower levels. Fundamentally, Tesla is egregiously overvalued with a P/E of 385x, forward P/E of 147x, P/S of 16.3x, and EV/EBITDA of 144x - all extrem

Bull Case(2 models)
DeepSeek-R10%

TSLA shows technical stabilization near $394 support with RSI(38) approaching oversold levels. High-volume node at $419 provides intermediate upside target, while alignment with AI/tech thematic tailwinds from NVDA earnings could spark momentum. Reward-to-risk ratio of 2.14:1 offers favorable asymmetry despite bearish regime.

Claude-Opus-4.5

TSLA is testing critical support at $394 with RSI at 38.31 showing oversold conditions and a rising RSI trend indicating potential momentum reversal. Price is currently near a low-volume node ($389-$392 area) which historically acts as a springboard for rapid price moves back toward the high-volume Point of Control at $435.94. The stock has pulled back nearly 20% from its 52-week high of $498.83, creating an attractive entry point for swing traders. The 2.73:1 reward-to-risk setup targeting the value area high at $430 offers compelling asymmetry. Tigress Financial recently initiated coverage w

What Would Invalidate
  • Close above $415 (stop level) would invalidate the breakdown thesis and signal support is holding, likely triggering move back toward value area and SMA resistance at $412-436
  • Daily close back above $416 (reclaiming the 20/50 SMA area and rejecting the breakdown) invalidates the short thesis.
  • Daily close below $393 support level with above-average volume
DeepSeek R1Deep
Analysis Outcome
LONG
5.00R·62% confidence
Entry
$400.00
Target
$435.00
Stop
$393.00

TSLA shows technical stabilization near $394 support with RSI(38) approaching oversold levels. High-volume node at $419 provides intermediate upside target, while alignment with AI/tech thematic tailwinds from NVDA earnings could spark momentum. Reward-to-risk ratio of 2.14:1 offers favorable asymmetry despite bearish regime.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BULL
Bull 62%Δ 2%Bear 60%
Bull Case

TSLA shows technical stabilization near $394 support with RSI(38) approaching oversold levels. High-volume node at $419 provides intermediate upside target, while alignment with AI/tech thematic tailwinds from NVDA earnings could spark momentum. Reward-to-risk ratio of 2.14:1 offers favorable asymmetry despite bearish regime.

Bear Case

Price below key SMAs with weak volume profile positioning signals breakdown risk. Regulatory overhang from DMV lawsuit and Autopilot rebranding creates fundamental headwinds. Extreme valuations (P/E 384) compound downside risk in bearish market regime.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BULL case won (62% vs 60%).

12m 56s26 tools
GPT-5.2Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
2.11R·61% confidence
Entry
$398.00
Target
$360.00
Stop
$416.00

SHORT bias on a breakdown/fade: TSLA is below key moving averages with bearish momentum and sitting on a fragile support shelf; if that shelf gives way, low-volume below can accelerate downside toward lower supports while macro risk-off and stretched valuation amplify selling pressure.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 61%Δ 3%Bull 58%
Bear Case

Technically, TSLA’s 4h structure is bearish: price is below the 20/50 SMAs (~ $412) , RSI is sub-50 (38) , and the chart is in a support-test near ~ $394—if that floor breaks, the volume profile shows a low-volume zone below current price, increasing odds of a fast air-pocket drop. Macro/regime context is a bearish transition with trending character and risk-off signals (small-cap under performance, flight-to-safety flows, VIX term structure flattening) , which typically pressures high-beta growth like TSLA (beta ~1.89) and makes rallies more likely to fade. Fundamentally, valuation looks stretched (P/E ~385, forward P/E ~147, EV/EBITDA ~144) with low profit margin (~4%) , leaving the stock vulnerable to multiple compression if sentiment deteriorates, while news flow includes regulatory/legal overhang and robotaxi safety concerns that can re-rate the narrative lower.

Bull Case

TSLA is testing a well-defined support zone near $394 on the 4h structure while RSI is oversold (~38) but rising, a common setup for a mean-reversion swing when sellers begin to exhaust. Volume profile shows price sitting in a low-volume area (~ $392– $399) , which often allows for faster upside travel back into the nearest high-volume nodes ( $419) and ultimately the point-of-control around ~ $436 where prior two-sided trade concentrated. With no clearly scheduled TSLA earnings within the next 1–3 weeks (reducing single-event gap risk) , the trade is framed as a technical rebound toward overhead supply/value rather than a fundamental re-rating.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (61% vs 58%).

4m 42s34 tools
Claude Opus 4.5Deep
Analysis Outcome
NO TRADE0% edge
BULL
58%
BEAR
58%

Bull and bear cases balanced — no clear edge

Bull/Bear CompetitionBALANCED
Bull 58%Δ 0%Bear 58%
Bull Case

TSLA is testing critical support at $394 with RSI at 38.31 showing oversold conditions and a rising RSI trend indicating potential momentum reversal. Price is currently near a low-volume node ($389-$392 area) which historically acts as a springboard for rapid price moves back toward the high-volume Point of Control at $435.94. The stock has pulled back nearly 20% from its 52-week high of $498.83, creating an attractive entry point for swing traders. The 2.73:1 reward-to-risk setup targeting the value area high at $430 offers compelling asymmetry. Tigress Financial recently initiated coverage with a $550 target, and 18 of 41 analysts maintain Buy ratings, suggesting institutional support remains intact. The legal battle with California DMV over FSD labeling, while creating short-term noise, could ultimately clarify the regulatory framework for Tesla's robotaxi ambitions. With no immediate earnings catalyst (next earnings April 2026) and price stabilizing after recent declines, a technical bounce toward the 20-day SMA at $412 and potentially the $430 resistance is the path of least resistance.

Bear Case

TSLA presents a compelling short setup with multiple converging bearish factors. Technically, the stock shows a "strong_bearish" signal with price trading below both SMA20 ( $412) and SMA50 ( $412) , MACD deeply negative at -5.44, and a "support_test" pattern that suggests breakdown risk. The volume profile reveals price is near low-volume nodes ( $389- $392) , meaning if support at $394 breaks, there's minimal volume support until significantly lower levels. Fundamentally, Tesla is egregiously overvalued with a P/E of 385x, forward P/E of 147x, P/S of 16.3x, and EV/EBITDA of 144x - all extreme multiples for an automaker with only 4% profit margins and declining EPS (last quarter missed by 31%) . The California DMV lawsuit over "deceptive marketing" of FSD creates regulatory overhang that threatens the robotaxi narrative, while significant insider selling by Kimbal Musk ( $25.6M) and CFO Taneja signals lack of confidence. The market regime is bearish with high risk level and flight-to-safety flows into gold/treasuries - exactly the wrong environment for high-beta growth stocks (TSLA beta: 1.89) . With only 44% of analysts at Buy and consensus at "Hold, " institutional support is lukewarm at best.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition CONTESTED: BULL case (58%) vs BEAR case (58%) - confidence delta (0%) below threshold. Trade skipped due to insufficient conviction.

3m 53s36 tools
Claude Sonnet 4.5Balanced
Analysis Outcome
SHORT
2.13R·62% confidence
Entry
$399.00
Target
$365.00
Stop
$415.00

TSLA exhibits severe technical deterioration with strong bearish signals (RSI 38.31, price -3% below both SMA 20/SMA 50, -20% from 52-week highs) in a trending bearish macro regime (80% confidence) . Most recent earnings on Jan 28 missed by -31.43%, a catastrophic miss signaling fundamental deterioration. Valuation is egregious at 385x P/E and 16.3x P/S with only 4% profit margins, making it vulnerable to multiple compression. California DMV lawsuit over Autopilot deceptive marketing creates regulatory overhang, while significant insider selling ( $25.6M by Kimbal Musk) signals lack of confidence. Volume profile shows Point of Control at $435.94 far above current price, with high-volume resistance nodes at $435-439 creating a ceiling. Price is testing support at $394 with next support at $365 (low-volume node at $389) , setting up breakdown risk.

Bull/Bear CompetitionWinner: BEAR
Bear 62%Δ 4%Bull 58%
Bear Case

TSLA exhibits severe technical deterioration with strong bearish signals (RSI 38.31, price -3% below both SMA 20/SMA 50, -20% from 52-week highs) in a trending bearish macro regime (80% confidence) . Most recent earnings on Jan 28 missed by -31.43%, a catastrophic miss signaling fundamental deterioration. Valuation is egregious at 385x P/E and 16.3x P/S with only 4% profit margins, making it vulnerable to multiple compression. California DMV lawsuit over Autopilot deceptive marketing creates regulatory overhang, while significant insider selling ( $25.6M by Kimbal Musk) signals lack of confidence. Volume profile shows Point of Control at $435.94 far above current price, with high-volume resistance nodes at $435-439 creating a ceiling. Price is testing support at $394 with next support at $365 (low-volume node at $389) , setting up breakdown risk.

Bull Case

TSLA is testing critical support at $394 with RSI at 38.31 showing deeply oversold conditions and rising momentum, creating a strong technical bounce setup. The stock is trading near a low-volume node ( $392.54) just 1.4% above support, suggesting limited downside before mean reversion toward the value area low ( $409) and POC ( $436) . Analyst consensus price target of $408 sits 2% above current levels, with high-conviction targets reaching $550 (Tigress Financial) , and recent retail interest surging 17.4% indicating accumulation at these depressed levels. The 1.92: 1 reward-to-risk setup targeting the $425 resistance zone (5.5x ATR move) offers asymmetric upside as TSLA recovers from -20% off 52-week highs.

Analysis Notes

Thesis Competition: BEAR case won (62% vs 58%).

3m 54s31 tools
TSLA Analysis | TradeHorde